Showing posts with label prostration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label prostration. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 20, 2026

Margaret of Hungary Does Pilates?

I've developed a new stretching routine, and have been reading up on Pilates lately (thanks to my enthusiast sister!), as I have become newly aware that there are muscles I apparently neglected to acquire during those Covid years. Oooouch.

This has also changed the way I read medieval saints' lives.

Take Margaret of Hungary. I’ve mentioned her before  -- she’s a thirteenth-century Dominican nun whose sisters were questioned about the sanctity of her life after her death. Time and again, they remembered what Margaret did with her body when she prayed. She didn't simply say prayers. She knelt, bowed, prostrated herself, stayed in uncomfortable positions, got up, and did it again.

Reading their testimony after reading about Pilates, I suddenly recognized something: Margaret had a prayer workout!

Not literally, of course. Margaret wasn't trying to improve her core strength, and she didn’t have any of those fancy machines. But prayer involved repeated physical actions, and doing those actions day after day trained her body just as surely as it trained her attention and devotion.

Here are three exercises from the Margaret of Hungary workout.

1. The medieval genuflection squat

Margaret's anonymous Life says that whenever she passed an image of Christ or the Virgin Mary, she greeted it by bending her knees. She did this so often that her kneecaps became swollen and callused.

Think about that spatially.

Every encounter with a sacred image required something from her body. Image: bend, rise, walk. Another image: bend, rise, walk....

In Pilates terms, that's repetition. The movement becomes automatic because you've done it approximately nine gazillion times and the instructor has somehow found another set of eight.

But religiously, something else is happening. Margaret is training herself to respond physically to sacred presence. Seeing produces movement. Reverence isn't just something she thinks or feels. Her body has learned what to do.

The calluses are therefore evidence of two kinds of formation at once: a body altered through repetition and a devotional habit made physical.

2. The thousand-veniae challenge

Then Margaret turns up the reps.

Multiple sisters testified that on major vigils Margaret performed one thousand veniae. A venia was a Dominican prostration: lowering the body to the ground and rising again.

And they really do mean a thousand. They cite the number repeatedly. (And even if it is only a stand in for “a whole lot of times in a row,” once you’ve done 30 reps of *anything* you can feeeeeel the burn.)

One witness says Margaret performed a thousand veniae with a thousand Ave Marias. Another specifies veniae on Marian vigils, for Veni Sancte Spiritus at Pentecost, and at the Pater noster at Christmas.

Try imagining the physical mechanics of that.

Down. Prayer. Up.

Down. Prayer. Up.

Only 998 more times to go.

That's where my Pilates analogy becomes useful. The individual movement isn't the whole practice. Repetition is the practice. Your body changes through doing the same thing again and again.

For Margaret, the verbal and physical repetitions were joined. One prayer, one movement; another prayer, another movement. Counting structured both.

And her body retained the history of doing it. After Margaret died, her former nurse and teacher Olimpiades remembered a callus on her knee, “rock-hard and as thick as an egg” (The Oldest Legend, p. 299), which she attributed to the many veniae Margaret had performed.

Pilates instructors generally prefer that you stop somewhat earlier.

3. Hold that position

My favorite testimony, though, concerns endurance.

Sister Candida once saw Margaret praying on her knees and elbows (The Oldest Legend, p. 395). Candida gives us an extraordinary measurement of how long she remained there: as long as it took Candida to read the entire Psalter.

Then a plank fell on Margaret's head. (A literal plank. I guess the carpenter hadn’t attached things well?)

Margaret still didn't move.

This is where the Pilates comparison gets weirdly appropriate.

Anyone who has held an oh-my-gosh-I’m-exercising-now plank—or watched the clock apparently cease functioning while holding one—knows that maintaining a position is an activity. Stillness requires work.

But Margaret's stillness also communicated something religious. Remaining physically fixed in prayer demonstrated the sustained attention that devotional writers repeatedly valued. Her body wasn't merely accompanying prayer. Holding the body in prayer was part of the act of praying.

And apparently falling lumber did not constitute sufficient reason to break form.

So was prayer medieval Pilates?

Obviously not.

Margaret wasn't secretly developing a thirteenth-century fitness program. In fact, her sisters sometimes thought her physical practices were excessive. Her convent superior, Magistra Olimpiades, reportedly complained that Margaret was praying with her “nose and face in the ground like a pig” and destroying herself (The Oldest Legend, pp. 371-373, 397).

But the comparison has made me notice something I might otherwise have read straight past.

We tend to encounter historical prayer as text. The sources preserve words, so we study the words: Ave Maria. Pater noster. Veni Sancte Spiritus.

The testimony about Margaret reminds us that prayer also had a body.

And as I’ve discussed elsewhere (Cyrus, Praying), bodies bent. They knelt. They lowered themselves to the floor and got up again. They held positions. They acquired calluses. Repeated gestures trained physical habits at the same time that repeated prayers trained devotional ones.

And that's why I love evidence like this.

A witness mentioning someone's swollen knees can suddenly recover something that the surviving prayer text cannot: what praying actually required a body to do.

Which is pretty cool.


REFERENCES

Cynthia J. Cyrus, “Praying Before the Image of Mary: Nuns’ Prayerbooks and the Mapping of Sacred Space,” Religions 16, no. 10 (2025): 1277. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel16101277.

Legenda vetus, Acta processus canonizationis; et, Miracula Sanctae Margaritae de Hungaria = The oldest legend; Acts of the canonization process; and, Miracles of Saint Margaret of Hungary, edited by Ildikó Csepregi, Gábor Klaniczay and Bence Péterfi, translated by Ildikó Csepregi, Clifford Flanigan and Louis Perraud (Budapest, Hungary; New York, NY: Central European University Press, 2018).

Images: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Arpadhazi_szent_margit.jpg and  www.freevector.com


YOU MIGHT ALSO BE INTERESTED IN

Dominican Prayer Gestures: How medieval Dominicans understood bows, genuflections, prostrations, and other bodily movements as meaningful parts of prayer—not just things the body happened to do while the mind got on with devotion.

Seven Times a Day: Prayer as Humane Practice: A different look at what repetition does to prayer: how regularly returning to an action can turn religious practice into habit—and habit into a way of structuring a life.

Passion, Pain, and the Work of Prayer: What happens when prayer asks the worshipper to engage imaginatively with Christ’s suffering? A look at pain, blood, attention, and the devotional work expected of the person praying.

Supple Rules for Prayer: Daston’s Ideas Meet the 16thc Prayerbook: How written rules and rubrics shaped women’s devotional practice at Thalbach—through the lens of Daston’s thinking about how rules for things actually work.

Saturday, March 29, 2025

Dominican Prayer Gestures (3/29/25)

Medieval prayer was not just a matter of words – it was a full-bodied practice, shaped by movement, posture, and gesture. As Jean-Claude Schmitt observes, such “[g]estures do not derive their meaning from their form but from their social use, from the context in which they were carried out” (p. 133). That is, we understand the significance of certain ways of holding the body and arms from the space in which they occur, the person or persons carrying them out, and the framing activities in which they are embedded.

This post briefly explores three twelfth- and thirteenth-century sources that illuminate the role of gesture in Dominican prayer: Peter the Chanter’s reflections on movement in devotion, Humbert of Romans’ structured taxonomy of bows and prostrations, and the treatises on Saint Dominic’s own prayer postures.

Together, these perspectives reveal how physical expression was not only an outward sign of inner devotion but also a communicative act, shaping and reinforcing the experience of prayer for both the individual and the community.

Peter the Chanter (d. 1197) tells us that prayer is a continuous movement. Take, for instance, his praise of the French at the moment of transubstantiation in the mass: 

these god-fearing men, I say, not only bend their head and kidneys but also remove all their hoods and caps from their heads, [and] prostrate themselves and fall on their face during the making and taking of the flesh and blood of Christ.

Four verbs in one short description: prayer for Peter is both active and sequential. Because of this, he considers gesture to be foundational for the act of praying. The positionality of the body matters in appropriately signaling the state of mind and spirit with which the petitioner approaches prayer. Here, Richard Trexler reminds us, we have submission postures. But to gesture, Peter reminds us, is an action, not an attitude. From a modern perspective, it’s a revelation of energy expended as well as engagement with the moment. Even when held in stasis – as with extended kneeling – the petitioner is putting physical energy into the act of prayer to supplement the verbal energy of the spoken prayer itself. Movement matters.

Trexler rightly points to the inconsistencies among the depictions as well as inconsistencies in Peter’s construction of the biblical authenticity for the seven gestures he articulates. Nevertheless, these “devote postures” are crafted to provide models of action in prayer. As Trexler summarizes, 

Peter the Chanter knew that the most sophisticated reader would learn body motions more quickly through pictures, and he wanted clerks to then act out his seven modes of prayer in a fashion which would edify spectators. Depersonalized figures would teach clerks, whose ritual life would then be the "book of the simple" (Trexler, p. 110).

Humbert of Romans (1200-1277) agrees with Peter the Chanter, at least in part: gesture matters, and it is imitable. Humbert, however, is less taken with ideas of movement and more with its visual endpoints. He offers a gestural grammar that explore the patterns of bending bodies in the context of the liturgy. Humbert provides a six-fold matrix of bows (inclinationes), genuflections (genuflexiones), and prostrations (prostrationes):

In his assessment of Humbert’s discussion, scholar Dmitri Zakharine points out that prostrations were an extended form of genuflection – “an amplification of the genuflection in liturgical ceremony.” (Zakharine, p. 349). He notes, however, that all these gestures had communicative power: they meant something to the petitioner, and, equally, they meant something to those who viewed these gestures.

It’s not unlike the teenager, arms akimbo. There is an authority of attitude inherent in these gestures if we see them in their proper context. For that teen with attitude, we’re mere steps away from the eye roll and the snarky comment. For the prayer-giver, we are in an opposite space, one in which the attitude reinforces a petitioning stance in the adoratio of the liturgy.

And Saint Dominic (1170-1221) himself explored a variety of stances in his prayer, at least as recorded in the multiple copies of The Nine [Alt: Fourteen] Ways of Praying of St Dominic. As Schmitt explores in detail, the illustrations to the Dominican treatise give us a wide range of gestures that Dominic was thought to have modeled.

That passive voice is doing some important work, because while the treatises agree in their hagiographical intent, they disagree, at least in part, about which prayer gestures were important enough to include. As Schmitt puts it, “the saint’s gestures quickly escaped pre-established codification of the inclinations” (Schmitt, p. 133).

The discussions of Dominic’s prayer in the treatise make clear that the captured gestures illustrated in the treatise iconography are part of a broader gestural complex. Take Dominic’s act of reading “some book opened before him.” Schmitt quotes the treatise: “He venerated his book, inclined himself toward it, kissed it with love.” In other words, the saint responded emotively and acted out his impulses in a set of actions – kissing the book, but also covering his head with his hood, or turning away from the book as if overwhelmed by its content. (Schmitt, p. 133)

This is important, because, pace Schmitt, the images and texts “offered a type of practical manual, a guide where the images presented more accurately the description of the gestures and moreover, the movement to imitate” (Schmitt, p. 140). In other words, the wise viewer might use the image as a model, for there is an “imitability” between friar and saint, reinforced by the choice of the vernacular. 

CONCLUSION

Given the differences in what they have to say, Peter, Humbert, and Dominic give us a rich view of medieval prayer gesture. For Peter the Chanter, the action is at the center of the gesture. These gestures reinforce the embodied nature of the petitioner, the life behind the words on the page or spoken into the air. For Humbert, the grammar of gesture is a central concern. He’s trying to think through the categories of meaningful acts, to give us the geometry of suitable self-abnegation, as the petitioner humbles him or herself before god. For Dominic, gesture is part of an almost theatrical construct, a staging in which bodily responses reinforce and make manifest the affective power of prayer.

Much like the implicit codes of modern body language, medieval prayer gestures carried with it meaningful information, shaping and being shaped by those who performed and witnessed them. Schmitt makes the point that prayer gestures were open to scrutiny by all – that one could see the forms of the prayer even if the words were only sub-vocal. Even in silence, the body spoke, making devotion visible to all who had eyes to see.


RESOURCES

Humbert of Romans. “Expositio super constitutiones fratrum praedicatorum.” In Opera Omnia, edited by Joachim Joseph Berthier, vol. 2: 160-167. Stuttgart: Klett Cotta, 1888-1889.

Schmitt, Jean-Claude. “Between Text and Image: the Prayer Gestures of Saint Dominic.” History and Anthropology 1 (1984): 127-162.

Trexler, Richard C. “Legitimating Prayer Gestures in the Twelfth Century. The De Penitentia of Peter the Chanter.” History and Anthropology, 1 (1984): 97-126.

Zakharine, Dmitri. “Medieval Perspectives in Europe: Oral Culture and Bodily Practices.” In Body - Language - Communication, Volume 1, edited by Cornelia Müller, Alan Cienki, Ellen Fricke, Silva Ladewig, David McNeill, Sedinha Tessendorf, pp. 343-364. Handbücher zur Sprach- und Kommunikationswissenschaft, 38,1. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 2013.

What does HMML sound like?

HMML has for me a distinct array of sounds. I thought a little Tell-and-Show might capture some untold aspects of my fellowship time. F...