Showing posts with label 16thc. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 16thc. Show all posts

Sunday, November 8, 2026

A Very Large G: Recognizing the Five Salutations in a Villingen Prayerbook


So there I was, scrolling through microfilm, as one does, and copying out the openings of prayers in Einsiedeln 654 (olim 1324). This little sixteenth-century communion prayerbook, from the Clarissan house of Villingen, has ninety-nine leaves. Its catalogue entry gives the main divisions, but – as is so often the case for prayerbooks – there is considerably more to discover among the individual prayers.

Near the end of the book, I encountered a most dramatic G: “Gegrützt sigistu herr Jhesu Christe…” – “Hail to you, Lord Jesus Christ.” The letter rises through roughly six lines if its excursion into the upper margin is included. The text has to retreat halfway across the column to make room for the capital letter. Shading in the monochrome microfilm suggests contrasting colors, and wavy inked ornament and feathering extend into the left margin. I don’t have permissions to reproduce the Einsiedeln image here, so you will have to take my word for it: this is a lovely letter.

It is also by size and by placement an attention-getter. Two- and three-line initials are common in this book. This one belongs to a much smaller group of especially prominent openings, alongside the Twelve Desires before communion (3r) and the Three Reverences before receiving the Sacrament (54v). That may not exactly give me a ranked list of the scribe’s favorite prayers, but it does at least tell me that this opening was given room to announce itself. What, I wondered, was being announced?

The prayer is just as lovely as its initial. Christ is greeted as the Lamb of God, the salvation of the world, a fountain of divine goodness, the flower and fruit of the Virgin Mary, the radiance of the heavenly Father, the prince of peace, the door of heaven, and the bread of life. One image spills out after another. Their abundance is part of the prayer’s appeal; each gives the person praying another way to address Christ.

But the sequence also supplies a clue. “Little lamb of God” is hardly an unusual title. Nor is “bread of life.” Finding either one somewhere else would tell us very little. It’s finding these titles in clusters, and then finding the clusters in the same order, that becomes a different matter. After running down the footnotes, this German prayer turns out to belong to the family of the Five Salutations of Jesus Christ, beginning in Latin “Ave Iesu Christe, verbum patris” (Baroffio 2021).

The large G had led me into a familiar prayer in another language. And although I cannot show the Villingen page, another women’s book lets us see its Latin relative.

Figure 1. Hermetschwil, Benediktinerinnenkloster, Cod. membr. 40, fol. 151r (e-codices). CC BY-NC 4.0. The first salutation begins on the preceding verso; this page continues it and supplies the remaining four. The Marian prayer beginning Gaude below is a separate text.

This fourteenth-century psalter was probably made for the Cistercian women of Selnau, near Zürich. By the seventeenth century it belonged to Sister Ottilia Sutter at the Benedictine convent of Hermetschwil. Its Five Salutations begin at the bottom of folio 150v and continue across the upper part of 151r. Red initials pick out the repeated Ave: “Hail” (Bretscher-Gisiger and Gamper 2005, 209–210).

To be clear, this is a Latin witness to the circulating prayer, not a proposed exemplar for the Villingen German version. Its value here is that it makes the pattern visible. We can turn the page and follow the greetings, just as a reader of the psalter could.

Selected correspondences between the Latin Five Salutations and the Villingen German version. Note: German excerpts have been lightly normalized from my working transcription.
Latin salutation Villingen German English sense
splendor patris ain schin vnd glantz des himelschen vatters radiance of the Father
vas deitatis ain vass der gotthaitt a vessel of divinity
lumen caeli des himels liecht light of heaven
fons amoris der brunn warer minn the fountain of true love

These correspondences occur in the same larger sequence of greetings. The third salutation gathers the Father’s radiance, the prince of peace, heaven’s door, living bread, and the vessel of divinity. The next begins with the light of heaven and the price of the world’s redemption. Then comes the greeting built around sweetness, truth, reward, and love. The German is recognizably related, even where its words do not follow the Latin exactly.

There is another wrinkle. The Five Salutations occupy only the beginning of the Villingen sequence, from 90v to 92r. The greetings keep going until 95v. They gather additional sacramental language and petitions: Christ as true body born of Mary, food for the journey, redemption, and help at death. The page’s visual divisions do not simply number off the five Latin salutations. The familiar prayer has been incorporated into a longer devotional sequence.

That is what makes the comparison interesting. Recognizing a prayer does not finish the work of reading it. It gives us a way to notice what this book does with it: which images it retains, where it changes the wording, and how it continues beyond the recognizable core.

Jenny C. Bledsoe’s study of an early fifteenth-century prayer roll now at the University of Pennsylvania adds another way of encountering the same prayer. On the roll, a Middle English story tells of a cleric in Burgundy who regularly greeted Mary in prayer. Christ promises his own friendship and help if the cleric will greet him too. What follows is only the Latin opening, Ave domine Iesu Christe, verbum patris. Bledsoe suggests that this cue assumes a reader who knows the prayer by heart (Bledsoe 2016, 197–198). Here a brief opening can summon a remembered prayer; in the Villingen book, the greetings are written out in German. The same circulating text could enter devotion through different combinations of language, writing, and memory.

For a musicologist, there is a further pleasure. It turns out, texts from these salutations also occur in the Milanese motet cycle Ave domine Iesu Christe, sometimes attributed to Loyset Compère. There, words encountered in prayerbooks become the material of polyphonic music, although the cycle combines and supplements the greetings, offering another adaptation of the prayer rather than an exact musical counterpart to the Villingen German version. And, of course, such a relationship does not tell us that the Villingen sisters sang this German version, but it does place their prayer within a repertory that could be read, spoken, and set to music (Filippi, MCE 2). (I would love to hear a performance of the cycle, which isn't available as a recording in any of my regular go-to-listen places!)

If the letter was a challenge, I think we're at "challenge met." It caught my attention, took me out to a Latin psalter, an English prayer roll, and a musical setting, and ultimately brought me back to the German text with better questions. I think at some level this is what manuscript decorations can do. That oversized and dramatic letter “G” made me stop, and look, and ponder the manifold meanings and contexts of the prayer.

YOU MIGHT ALSO BE INTERESTED IN

WORKS CITED

Manuscripts

  • Einsiedeln, Stiftsbibliothek, Cod. 654 (olim 1324), fols. 90v–95v; the Five Salutations at 90v–92r. German communion prayerbook, Villingen, St. Klara (Bickenkloster), sixteenth century. Work consulted via microfilm from the Hill Museum and Manuscript Library, HMML 48672.
  • Hermetschwil, Benediktinerinnenkloster, Cod. membr. 40, fols. 150v–151r. Psalterium, southwestern Germany, fourteenth century; probably made for the Cistercian convent of Selnau. Digital facsimile: e-codices. Figure 1 reproduces fol. 151r, and the blog post announcement includes the elaborate "A" for "Ave Iesu Christe" that starts the cycle on fol. 151v. Both images CC BY-NC 4.0.
  • Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania, Kislak Center for Special Collections, Rare Books and Manuscripts, MS Roll 1563. Latin and Middle English prayer roll, early fifteenth century. Discussed in Bledsoe 2016, especially 197–198.

Studies and reference works

  • Baroffio, Giacomo. Corpus Italicum Precum: Materiali per una storia del sentimento religioso in Italia e in Europa. Version dated 16 April 2021. Entries under Ave Iesu Christe.
  • Bledsoe, Jenny C. “A Late Medieval Macaronic Prayer Roll: UPenn MS Roll 1563.” Notes and Queries 63, no. 2 (June 2016): 196–199. https://doi.org/10.1093/notesj/gjw079.
  • Bretscher-Gisiger, Charlotte, and Rudolf Gamper. Katalog der mittelalterlichen Handschriften der Klöster Muri und Hermetschwil. Dietikon-Zürich: Urs Graf Verlag, 2005, 209–210. Description of Cod. membr. 40 reproduced on e-codices.
  • Ferro, Eva. “ ‘Old Texts for New Music’? Textual and Philological Observations on the Cycles ‘Salve Mater Salvatoris’ and ‘Ave Domine Iesu Christe’ from Librone 1.” In Motet Cycles between Devotion and Liturgy, edited by Daniele V. Filippi and Agnese Pavanello, 189–218. Basel, 2019.
  • Filippi, Daniele V., ed. MCE 2: [Loyset Compère?], Ave domine Iesu Christe. Motet Cycles Edition, Musik-Akademie Basel. https://doi.org/10.48523/zdxh-7324. The attribution to Compère is debated. 
  • Lang, Odo. Katalog der Handschriften in der Stiftsbibliothek Einsiedeln. Zweiter Teil: Codices 501–1318. Basel, 2009, 216: Cod. 654 (1324).

Funding: This research was supported by a Carpenter Fellowship from the Hill Museum and Manuscript Library (HMML). I am grateful to HMML’s staff for their assistance, hospitality, and support during my residency.

Friday, November 6, 2026

What’s yours is mine: a tale of greed at the closure of a monastery


There once were a set of sisters at Talheim bei Mössingen. They lived and prayed and made a life together. And then the Reformation came.

They were beloved of their neighbors, even though, for more than a generation, they stayed on as the Catholic holdovers in a mostly Protestant town. Why do we think so? They served as Godmothers – multiple times – in the local Protestant church register. Religious differences were evidently less important than social connection and pious behavior in the eyes of the broader community.

Such connectedness, however, did not actually help them much when it did come time for the convent to shutter its doors. During these closing years, the convent had been secularized, but the sisters were – in theory – permitted to reside there until death. Theory and practice, however, do not always align.

And this is where our lively cast of characters comes in. Let’s meet them in social-hierarchy order:

  • DUKES: Protestant Duke Ludwig of Württemberg, and his successor Duke Friedrich, generally well-intentioned but not always on top of the details. They know a thing or two about authority, though!
  • ASSISTANCE PROVIDED BY: the Catholic Count of Fürstenberg, where the sisters held properties. He supports them, but sometimes that support takes strange shapes!
  • EVIL-DOING LOCAL NOBLE: Caspar von Karpffen, holder of a quarter of the town of Talheim and always eager for more. See also his daughter Sabina, and Sabina’s husband Christoph von Karpffen: The von Karpffen family demands all the sisters' things – and Caspar holds two sisters hostage until they deed away their property. Then it really gets ugly.
  • FUERSTENBERG BAILIFF from Trochtelfingen: to help with the tussle, he too abducts a sister. “To protect her.” With friends like these, who needs enemies? This act draws the ire of the Württemberg dukes, and then absolutely everyone (except the sisters) engages in a big game of "No, no, no, MY authority."

The story itself goes like this.

In 1593, Caspar von Karpffen imprisoned two sisters in Talheim Castle, supposedly because of offenses they had committed. What offenses? Theodor Schön, whose 1890 account supplies this story, does not explain. Nor is it a one-week lockup situation: he keeps them imprisoned for two years. He finally releases them in 1595, after they sign an agreement to give him all their property. He “generously” promises them an allowance. Insert maniacal laughter clip here.

Because, yeah, the amount he pays them is so small, they couldn’t afford their bread on a daily basis. I guess eating is optional? Anyway, that’s von Karpffen in a nutshell: a nasty piece of work.

Nor was this simply a matter of taking over their fields while leaving the sisters comfortably housed (as the legal agreements stipulated). Oh, no. Silverware, church ornaments, bedding, livestock: their movable possessions went to the von Karpffen household too. And he wasn’t done: after stripping away the means of supporting themselves and the little luxuries like blankets and eating utensils, Karpffen continued to demand that they pay taxes, including the extensive Turkish levy, along with further burdens and exactions. Not even begging could make up this deficit.

And sometimes the help that you get is… complicated. The Count of Fürstenberg intervened, but for reasons that remain obscure to me, his bailiff forcibly removed a sister. “For her protection” is kind of vague. Here, let me abduct you to keep you safe. Ummmm, not sure that’s a win.

Nor was it deemed politically proper. Von Karpffen – in whose territory the sisters still live, be it remembered – complained to Duke Ludwig. In his version of the story, Fürstenberg support was a vile intrusion into Württemberg’s jurisdiction for no reason at all. Instead of asking what was going on (the dukes, not always ones for asking for fussy details like “and what did the victim say”), the duke had the bailiff arrested – and also had him fined 200 guilders. When doing your job actually costs you money; the bailiff wasn’t having a very good day.

So there we are. The first two sisters had been released, but into abject poverty. Another sister has been carried off, and the official response becomes a dispute over whose official was entitled to do what, and where. The women’s predicament had become an occasion for men to defend their rights of government. Neener-neener.

Yet those competing claims also gave the sisters somewhere to turn. Duke Ludwig initially accepted Karpffen’s account, but he wasn’t bad at heart. He actually intervened on the sisters’ behalf once he learned more. Crucially, Schön reports that Ludwig considered the punishment of the sisters beyond Karpffen’s authority. That two-year arrest had been out of bounds.

It was going well for the sisters, but then Duke Ludwig died before he could bring the matter to a satisfactory conclusion. Sigh. His successor, Friedrich, however, continued to work on the intervention, trying to sort through competing claims, and tending to the needs of his subjects, ALL of his subjects.

So what happened? Duke Friedrich reprimanded von Karpffen, and then summoned the parties before the ducal chancellery. But it feels just like a present-day story: the judge commands, but Karpffen failed to appear. Officials went to him. He supplied excuses, poor excuses. Plus, he refused to return the property.

Eventually, under renewed pressure, von Karpffen yielded—but with a reservation, of course. The sisters could have their property back, but after their deaths, he claimed, it should come to him.

The Württemberg officials had other things to do. So they accepted the transfer without actually settling whether that future claim had any validity. For the moment, the women could resume possession, have their land cultivated, gather the harvest, and collect outstanding rents. Most of their property was recovered.

You might think this would be the point at which von Karpffen admitted defeat. You would be wrong.

In July 1601, he had his local official remove the sisters’ hay from their meadows. Hay. They have a showdown over a field of hay.

But hay gets your livestock through the winter. It is an asset: stored nourishment, future milk, the means of keeping your valuable animals alive. How would you like it if the local noble decided to help himself to your vacation fund—and to your winter’s food budget? And then sent you the tax bill on top of that?

Taking the hay was actually an attack on the sisters’ ability to make use of the property they had just recovered. Possession on paper was one thing. Getting the harvest safely home was another. You can tell me what to do, but you can’t make me do it.

So the sisters did what they had to do: they filed another complaint. This time, Friedrich ordered his officials to uphold their restored possession. And on July 27, the Württemberg Schultheiß, a local governing magistrate, arrived at the meadow. Nor did he come alone. Tempers were getting short, and von Karpffen needed a lesson. So the Württemberg magistrate showed up with approximately thirty peasants armed with spears and pitchforks. (Insert visual mob scene from any historic film you’ve ever seen, with raging peasants and a sense of urgency.) They drove away Karpffen’s rival official – and then they hauled off the hay.

Thirty peasants. Spears. Pitchforks. Two competing officials. The hay now had an armed escort.

After which, naturally, came the lawyers.

On April 3, 1602, the two sisters, Veronica Waldträffin and Apollonia Spindlerin, appointed Sebastian Wolf to represent them. I particularly like this detail. These women mostly appear passive in the account; they serve as prisoners, dependents, and objects of protection. Here, on the other hand, we see them taking direct action: securing legal representation to defend their interests. I guess the time had come!

Von Karpffen, meanwhile, obtained a mandate from the Imperial Chamber Court awarding him the disputed hay – or its value if it was no longer available – with a substantial penalty attached to noncompliance. Schön attributes this result to “false representations,” and I’ll take his word on the point, having not read the court records myself. So von Karpffen’s not just a scheming meany; he’s a lying scheming meany. Got it.

Imagine being the sisters. You’ve recovered your property through ducal intervention. Someone takes your harvest. The duke’s men recover it. And now an imperial court says the man who took it is actually owed the hay.

The duke submitted objections. But it’s a legal case; long-lived and complicated. The dispute outlived Caspar von Karpffen, who died in 1603. It also outlived Duke Friedrich, who died in 1608.

Eventually, it outlived the sisters.

And this is where the family connections matter. Caspar had already assigned his claim to the convent to his son-in-law, Christoph, as a marriage portion for his daughter Sabina. Property that still supported living religious women had now been promised as somebody else’s marriage settlement.

Brazen thievery apparently works. After the last sister’s death, Christoph von Karpffen took possession. And, as Schön’s account shows, the convent and its estates subsequently passed through further family marriage arrangements.

What’s yours is mine. And then it’s my daughter’s dowry. And her daughter’s beyond that. And so on, and so on, and so on.

There is one final complication. Schön tells this story with considerable indignation, but his concluding concern is that property intended for religious purposes ended up in private hands. He praises the Württemberg dukes for preserving former Catholic church wealth for Protestant ecclesiastical uses. His preferred outcome was that Württemberg should acquire the estate and devote at least part of it to church purposes.

That makes the dukes’ role worth examining carefully. Their interventions materially helped the sisters. Their interests also extended to what would happen after the women were gone.

For the sisters, meanwhile, the urgent questions were rather more immediate. Could they get their property back? Collect their rents? Keep their bedding? Feed their animals through another winter? Did they ever get their knives, forks, and spoons back?

They had neighbors who named them godmothers, officials who intervened, a lawyer to represent them, and a duke willing to send thirty armed peasants into a meadow.

And still they had to fight for the hay.


WORKS CITED

Gerhard Kittelberger, “Franziskanerinnenkloster Talheim”, Klöster in Baden-Württemberg, http://www.kloester-bw.de/?nr=538. Kittelberger’s entry alerted me to the story. 

Beschreibung des Oberamts Rottenburg, second edition, vol. II (Stuttgart: W. Kohlhammer, 1900), p. 353-4. Includes a summary of the sisters’ Statutes of 1401 and contextual details.

Theodor Schön, “Die letzten Schicksale des Beguinenklosters zu Thalheim im Oberamt Rottenburg,” Blätter für württembergische Kirchengeschichte 5 (1890): 82–84. Best German-language rendition of the story. 

And yes, I enjoyed this tale well enough to pursue it bibliographically even though it WASN'T on my list of things to do! 


YOU MIGHT ALSO BE INTERESTED IN

Kin, Cash, and Convent: Providing for Nieces (and Nephews) in 1613 Bludenz: A determined aunt uses her will to support a niece’s religious future—with conditions attached. Another encounter with convents, inheritance, and the family politics of deciding who gets what.

When the Gestapo Came for the Sisters: A much later chapter in the history of forced convent closures, drawn from testimony preserved in the Nuremberg Trial records. The consequences reached beyond cloister walls into schools, charitable work, and the communities the sisters served.

Listening in on the Nuns’ Rebellion at Kloster Goldenstein: What happens when sisters refuse to accept that someone else has finished deciding where they belong? Three elderly nuns of the present-day reclaim their convent, and their familiar sounds of prayer and daily life become an assertion of their right to remain.

Friday, July 31, 2026

Supple Rules for Prayer: Daston’s Ideas Meet the 16thc Prayerbook

I’ve been re-reading Lorraine Daston’s Rules: A Short History of What We Live By (which is brilliant -- you should go read it yourself!), and thinking about its relevance for the sixteenth-century prayerbooks that are so much part of my life right now.

Rules, Daston tells us, are important, but the best rules are thick rules; they are specific, yes, but they are also supple. They come with examples, and exceptions, and mechanisms of interpretation that don’t get befouled by absolutist thinking. Circumstances change; people get sick; time runs short. And yet in all three instances, the goal of the rule presumably still applies. A little judgment, she argues, goes a long way toward effective implementation of “the rule.” (Her chapter 2 discussion of the Benedictine rule is particularly fruitful for understanding this perspective.)

What I want to do here is play a bit with what this might mean in the context of the sixteenth-century prayerbook copied for women’s use. I’ve chosen the most ornate of the Thalbach Prayerbooks, ÖNB Cod. 11750, again, since it represents Thalbach at its most careful. “Nice” hand, carefully organized layout, clear directions, many labels, distinction between the red-ink rubrics and the brown-ink text. It’s tidy, in other words. But it also shows a tidiness of approach, in that it frequently offers up prefatory instructions to a prayer that guide the reader into the appropriate stance, place, movement, mindset. It’s what I think of short-hand as prayer choreography.

So I’m here to ask: what if we think of those rubrics as “thick rules” instead of “verbal choreography”? What do we gain? In one sense, of course, the answer is obvious: rubrics tell readers what to do. But Daston’s account of thick rules helps me ask a more precise question: not whether rubrics direct practice, but what kind of practice they assume, enable, and refine.

Rules that are not rule-bound

It is easy, especially from a modern distance, to read rubrics primarily as instruments of control: say this, do that, turn here, kneel there. But in a pre-modern devotional manuscript, a rubric may be less like a traffic sign and more like a craft instruction. It tells the practitioner what kind of action is called for, while assuming that the practitioner already inhabits a world in which the action makes sense.

Are rubrics rules? Yes—but I think they are rules of practice rather than regulations of compliance.

ÖNB Cod. 11750, fol 15r; texts have been lightly normalized by the author.

Ein schön Gebet, damit alle Glieder unseres Herrn gegrüßt werden, vor einem Crucifix zu sprechen. GEGRJESST ſeyeſtu du aller heilligſt haubt vnnſers lieben herrn Jesu christi welches für unns gekrönt mit dörnen vnd geschlagenn mit einem ror….

A beautiful prayer with which all the limbs of our Lord are honored, to be recited before a crucifix. HAIL to you, most holy head of our dear Lord Jesus Christ, which for us was crowned with thorns and struck with a reed….”

We have here several elements: a description (a beautiful prayer), a content summary (with which all the limbs of our Lord are honored), and the part I am thinking of as being the rule: performative details of how and of where the prayer is to be delivered – it is to be recited (sprechen) before a Crucifix.

This isn’t complex. The supplicant isn’t drowning in detail. She’s merely guided to a best practice in prayer delivery, shifted to a space where sight (the crucifix) can reinforce the task of prayer (to consider in turn each of the body parts of the suffering Lord of the crucifixion. As a rule goes, it organizes her prayer, binding text, image, body, and gaze into a whole.

It’s a bit like “craft knowledge.” The rubric assumes some proficiency; the supplicant will know when the prayer might be useful, But it guides her through specificity of where she should stand, what she should face, and how she should let the image structure her attention. In so doing, it invokes a practice of visual, affective, and bodily meditation.

Yet this “rule” is supple too; this isn’t necessarily the crucifix of the main altar at the parish church. She could read this prayer in front of the crucifix by the convent refectory, or the one in her cell, or by flipping back a few folios and gazing at the image of the Crucifixion that adorns OENB 11750 folio 8r. The gaze will guide, but how she achieves the gaze is flexible enough to accommodate a variety of circumstances.

That’s a nuance that I didn’t think to talk about when thinking of the instruction as choreography. So, one point for Daston’s utility.

Rules for transitions

A rubric makes the page actionable, but can also provide guidance for time-of-day transitions, from the mundane to the spiritual, from the world-oriented to the spirit-oriented, from the activity of daytime to the closure of bedtime ritual.

If the crucifix rubric shows how a rule can organize devotional attention around an object, the bedtime rubric for our next prayer (OENB 11750 fol. 3v-5r) shows how a rule can organize an ordinary daily transition. I like this intervention, since it gives the actions as a set: first the rubric provides a label, then the confession, then the guiding script to ready the supplicant for bed:

Bedtime ritual (OENB 11750 fol. 3v-5r, excerpts):

Volgen schuene gebet so man schlafen geeth

The following are beautiful prayers to be said before going to sleep.

So du ietzund wilt ſchlafen gen: so sprich dise bekantnus der ſunden. Alſo. ICH bekenne dir Herr Allmechtiger Gott erſchaffer himel vnd der Orden alle meine ſünd die ich gethon hab von meiner Iugent an bis diſe zeit vnnd ſtund...

So now you wish to go to sleep: then say this confession of sins. Thus: I confess to you, Lord Almighty God, creator of heaven and earth, all my sins that I have committed from my youth until this time and hour….

Wan du gleich in dz Beth schlaffenn gehst so bezaichne dich mit dem Zeihen des ehilligen Creitz an dem stirn, und sprich also: Iesus von Nazareth sey allezeit mein abeschiirmer. (An deiner mund) Jesus von Nazareth sei allezeit in meinen mu/ond. (An dein brüst) Jesus von Nazareth sey al zeitt in meinem hertznn. Amen. [PRAYER]: O Lieber herr Jesu Christe, nur will / ich dise rüo vnd aüffenthalltung meines leibs empfahenn, in der verantigunng deiner lieb gegen vns dardürch dü vns den ſchlaf zu guttem geben hast auch desselben…

When you go to sleep in your bed, make the sign of the holy cross on your forehead, and say thus: Jesus of Nazareth, be my protector at all times. (On your mouth) Jesus of Nazareth, be always in my mouth. (On your breast) Jesus of Nazareth, be always in my heart. Amen. [PRAYER] O dear Lord Jesus Christ, I now wish to receive this rest and repose of my body, in acknowledgment of your love for us, through which you have given us sleep for our good, and also...

It’s sort of like the modern ritual: first you turn off the TV, then you brush your teeth, then you climb into bed and take up the work of stilling your mind.

What’s special in the Thalbach rubric is that it provides a bodily procedure, marking the forehead, mouth, and breast, along with accompanying words. It’s apotropaic, yes, spiritually protective, but it’s also that kind of Daston middle-ground. The instruction is specific, but it’s non-narrative. There’s no need to explain every theological or bodily assumption. It presupposes habit – a practitioner who already has insider knowledge: how to make the sign of the cross, why sleep is spiritually vulnerable, and how short verbal formulae can guard thresholds.

The rubric turns ordinary sleep into a devotional exercise. It does not regulate sleep bureaucratically; it ritualizes that regular daily transition. It is, to use the common convention, a habit-stacking rule.

Again, “choreography” thinking me was VERY excited about all the actions in this rubric, but the “rule”-based assessment is more empathetic to the time-of-day and purpose-driven nature of the actions involved.

Prayer as craft knowledge

Early modern rules, in Daston’s account, assume prior experience and promise improvement, particularly when the stem from the artist’s workshop. They systematize and extend experience rather than replacing it. They are designed, she argues, to be learned but also practiced.

“To formalize craft knowledge into rules was to give it voice and dignity but not to remove it from the workshop. Dürer intended his instructions as a 'thorough introduction' to be expanded by 'daily use,' which in turn would deepen understanding and kindle invention.” (Daston p. 51)

This observation was particularly exciting to me, since there are so many similarities here with prayer as codified in prayerbooks. Prayer as something learned through repeated, bodily, attentive practice. If we draw the parallel out, we could think of prayer in prayerbooks as a mechanical art, separate from the theological and argumentatively-grounded work of the university setting. As a craft, it fits into a realm of acquired-and-enacted wisdom.

The fit is imperfect, of course. Daston’s artisans are often making things: pictures, fortifications, meals, calculations. The Thalbach reader is not producing an external artifact in the same sense. She is cultivating attention, protection, repentance, and memory. The “thing” being shaped is not primarily an artifact but the praying self: attention, contrition, memory, bodily readiness, protection, and receptivity and capacity to return to God. That difference matters because the prayerbook rule is not only guiding what she does; it is helping shape how she becomes disposed to pray.

Nor do I mean that prayer was mechanical in the sense of being merely manual, servile, or technical. But I do want to invoke Daston’s ideas to argue that prayer has craft-like dimensions. It is learned by repetition. It uses tools. It depends on timing, memory, posture, voice, attention, sequence, and correction. It can be done badly, habitually, fluently, intensely, communally, or with practiced skill.

Daston provides a summary of craft-rule guidance:

“rules were always framed in the imperative mood… , the knowledge in question was often gleaned from personal experience ….seldom addressed to rank beginners … the promised payoff of mastering the rules was improvement.”

Yes! That tracks for prayerbooks too:

1) Rubrics are typically imperative, if not always in a strict grammatical sense. Many are titles or summaries, occasions for use, or navigational cues. But they are directive all the same: they tell the reader how a text is to be used. I think that gets at the “imperative mood” element pretty effectively.

2) Similarly, they share the wisdom of previous enactments in capsule form.

3) They assume a familiarity with context and pattern, so are not “beginner books” (those are psalters!) but more the “intermediate-to-advanced” guide helpful to honing one’s personal practice. The implied reader already knows many of the gestures, formulae, and devotional contexts being cued.

4) And, as Daston argues, improvement is the goal.

In other words, OENB 11750 treats prayer as a practiced art both in the sense of being enacted and in the sense of being repeated. It assumes that technique will help devotion take on durable form.

The morning prayer sequence of Segen and prayer (OENB 11750 5v-7r) illustrates this practice. It’s not a beginner’s catechism; it’s a set of cues for someone already embedded in devotional habits. It uses cross-reference, and embodied action, and praise texts to start the day in a positive and spirtually grounded way:

Segen and prayer for morning (OENB 11750 5v-7r, excerpts):

Segen vnnd Gebett: Wann man am morgen vom Schlaf auf steth IN dem Namen des Vatters des Suns vnd des heilligenn Geists….

Blessing and Prayer: When one rises from sleep in the morning In the name of the Father, the
Son, and the Holy Spirit...

Zaichne dich darauf / an dein stirn mit dem ʒeichen des heilligenn Creütz vnd ſprich. Jeſus von Nazareth ꝛc. wie oben steth. Darnach knien ider vnd sprich. ICH bette dich an vnd lobe dich O du heillige Driualtigkeit du mein Gott alles in allem ich ſage dir danckh für alle bewarung weissheit vnnd guettigkeit...

Make the sign of the cross on your forehead with the sign of the holy cross and say: Jesus of Nazareth, etc., as stated above. Then kneel and say: I adore you and praise you, O holy Trinity, my God, all in all. I thank you for all protection, wisdom, and goodness...

In the first portion, there’s no need to tell the informed reader that she’s to speak these words; the ink-color transition is obvious and her actions implicit. In the second half of this text, her knowledge of the standard Jesus of Nazareth formula that she’d said just the night before saves the scribe some valuable parchment space. In Daston’s terms, these rubrics offer a system and occasion for practice. But, as she reminds us, this was already a great deal: experience refracted through the lens of the rules of art was better ordered, more sharply focused, and above all broader than that of most craftsmen occupied with the pell-mell of particulars encountered in their own workshops” (Daston p. 69)

Again, yes for the prayerbooks too.

Conclusion: rubrics as supple rules for living

Thalbach’s devotional books preserve not only texts but habits of life. Their rubrics belong to a world in which rules were not necessarily the enemy of vitality. Rather, rules were one way of making practice durable. The question, then, is not simply whether rubrics direct practice. Of course they do. The more interesting question is what kind of practice they imagine, and here the answer is more nuanced. They imagine one that is repeated, embodied, adaptive, and interiorly formative.

To read rubrics as rules, then, is not to flatten prayer into procedure. It is to take seriously the practiced intelligence of devotional life. It is to treat prayer as practiced and ever-renewed: a craft of spirituality in which small guiding texts could lead to improvement -- a more ordered disposition, better attention, more durable memory, more ready access to words and gestures, a more practiced capacity to return to God.

I don’t think reading rubrics as rules replaces the choreography model so much as it shifts the emphasis. “Choreography” catches the embodied sequence; “rule” catches the learned, repeatable, adaptable form. Drawing on both perspectives gives us the fuller picture.

Considered through Daston’s lens, the Thalbach sister’s manuscript does not simply tell its reader what to say. Its rubrics teach the reader when to pray, how to begin, where to stand, what to face, what to repeat, how to move the body, and how to carry liturgical forms into the ordinary hours of life. Its rules are specific enough to guide action and, critically, supple enough to live with. In that sense, these prayerbook rubrics belong not only to the history of books, but to the history of how people learned to inhabit devotion.

WORKS CITED

Lorraine Daston, Rules: A Short History of What We Live By (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2022).

On habit-stacking, I found Clear’s version substantially less smarmy than some of the more industrial “habit-stacking” banged-it-out-for-a-buck narratives out there on the market: James Clear, Atomic Habits: An Easy & Proven Way to Build Good Habits & Break Bad Ones (2018).

For a somewhat more choreographic assessment of such rubrics, see Cynthia Cyrus, "Praying Before the Image of Mary: Nuns’ Prayerbooks and the Mapping of Sacred Space" Religions 16, no. 10 (2025): 1277. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel16101277, https://www.mdpi.com/3532324

Other posts on OENB 11750:

Friday, February 13, 2026

Threefold Illumination: A Nun’s Prayer After Communion

The spiritual quest for three-fold illumination -- knowledge of self; knowledge of God’s love; and knowledge of (and surrender to) God’s will -- is mapped out in the most ornate of the Thalbach Prayerbooks, ÖNB Cod. 11750, at the very end of a long mass prayer cycle. This prayer is seated firmly within a Franciscan orbit with its characteristic affective spirituality, reflective of late 16th-century habits of thought. The text is staunchly Catholic in perspective, for it assumes a very concrete Eucharistic theology: grace is mediated through the sacrament itself (durch krafft dis Sacraments), not just through prayer. Here we see a Catholic woman at the conclusion of a Catholic liturgy, participating in deeply rooted and very specifically Catholic devotional practices.We are anchored here to faith.

The prayer starts with a kind of self-abasement which may read as uncomfortable to modern eyes. The abnegations pile up: wickedness, vileness, worthlessness, ingratitude, insult, shame: through such self-knowledge (!) she asks to come to humility, repentance, and sorrow for my sins. Seeing the bad in order to correct her faults is strategic, a spiritual confession that moves toward the relief of forgiveness. This is classic penitential piety shaping belief and practice in practical, implementable ways. Yet for our modern eyes, the absence of positive self-knowledge is a gap here; this first illumination only tangentially touches on love and forgiveness, making it harder for the passage to resonate with in a more self-affirming age.

The second illumination focuses on love (liebe), used five times in as many lines, matching it with her heart, which must be enlightened, wounded, filled, and then come to thirst. Thus, God’s love toward “us” becomes her love towards God, loved “at all times, in all things, and above all things.” This is lyricism at its finest, repetitiveness deployed as a metaphor of spiritual growth on a properly chosen model. Very Franciscan, and with echoes of Thomas à Kempis or pseudo-Bonaventure in its patternings:

O God, my Lord, I beg you once again through your tender mercy, enlighten my heart to recognize and love your goodness and love for us. I beg you, wound my heart with the purest, most faithful, and fervent love towards us, O sweet Jesus, fill my heart with your most perfect, fervent, and unquenchable love, so that I may always thirst for you with all my heart, and that I may love you at all times, in all things, and above all things.

The enlightened heart, then, comes to fulfill the third illumination: self-denial and self-surrender, a self-rededication to the monastic calling from which she prays. She wants strengthened the scope of her devotion to encompass “all the actions and powers” of both body and soul. By moving from abnegation through love to action, she is transforming herself here at this moment, repurposing her spirit to accomplish God’s ends.

The sacrament, then, has accomplished its function. It does not merely forgive sin; it illuminates the mind, reshapes the affections, and reorders the will toward God’s action, serving as an agent of interior transformation. In this brief prayer we see how sacramental devotion worked in practice: not as a single moment of absolution, but as an ongoing process of spiritual formation rooted in Franciscan ideals of humility, love, and surrender.


“O Ewiger liebhabender barmhertziger Gott erleucht mein hertz,” Thalbach Prayerbook, ÖNB Cod. 11750, fol. 47v-48v, Transcription and Translation CC-BY-NC Cynthia J. Cyrus

Du magſt auch bitten vmb dreifaltige erleichtung/ dz dir ſolche / durch krafft dis Sacraments mitgetailt werde.

[3-line initial] O Ewiger liebhabender barmhertziger Gott erleucht mein hertz/ Dz ich meīn aigne bossheit ſchnödigkeit nichtigkeith vnnd vndanckbarkeit moͤg erkennen/ also dz ich ab ſolchem ein geburenden mÿsfallenn hab • Laß mich erkennen. O Guettiger Jeſu wie ich ſo gar nichts bin noch kan, vnd dz ich mich ſelbs veracht. Gib mir aüch, dz ich von hertzen von der Welt beger uerarcht zu werdenn, dz ich wünsch diemüettig zu sein: vnd vnbild vnd schmach zu leiden mich erfrewe. Eya du mein guettigſter herr Jhesu, geůſin mich ware erkantnus meiner ſelbſt auch volkomne demůott, rew vnd laid v̈ber meine begangne Sünnd.

O Gott mein herr ich bitte dich abermals durch dem Jimierliche barmhertzigkeit erleüchte mein hertz dem guettigkeit vnnd liebe gegen vns zu erkennen vnd zu lieben Jch bitte verwunde mein hertz mit keuschister getrewester vnd inbrünstiger liebe gegen vns O ſueſſer Jeſu, erfulle mein hertz mit deiner volkomesten, inbrünstigen vnd vnauſloͤſchkichen liebe / damit mich allzeit vongantzem hertzenn nach dür dürste, vnd dz ich dich ieder zeit in allem vnd vber alles liebe /

O Guettigster Jhesu, mein Gott vnnd alles in allem / Ich bitte dich / erleicht mein hertz/ deinen wolgefallen zu erkennen, zu lieben vnd volbrüngen. Gib mir vollkomesten erlaugnüng vnd aufergebüng meiner ſelbſt / darmit ich mich, selbs aüff Alle weiSS uerlaSS / aus mir gehe / vnd mich auffer gebe zuallem deinē wolgefallenn, Gib mir / dz ich mich ganz vnd gar deiner für ſehüng vertrawe / alle ding von deiner Hannd mit dancksagung annemmen vnd in allem dich lob vnd benedeÿe. Verschaffe O guettiger Gott/dz ich all mein leben alle zeit alles thunvnnd krefften meiner leibs vnd meiner Seelen und alles wz ich bin vnd vermag zu deinem lob Lieb vnd wolgefallen darraiche vnnd dargebe, Amen.

You may also ask for threefold illumination, that this may be imparted to you through the power of this sacrament.

O eternal, loving, merciful God, enlighten my heart, that I may recognize my own wickedness, vileness, worthlessness, and ingratitude, so that I may have a proper displeasure at it. Let me recognize, O good Jesus, how completely I am nothing and can do nothing, and that I may hold myself in contempt. Grant me also that I may wholeheartedly desire to be despised by the world, that I may wish to be humble, and that I may rejoice in suffering insult and shame. O my most gracious Lord Jesus, grant me true knowledge of myself, also perfect humility, repentance, and sorrow for my sins.

O God, my Lord, I beg you once again through your tender mercy, enlighten my heart to recognize and love your goodness and love for us. I beg you, wound my heart with the purest, most faithful, and fervent love towards us, O sweet Jesus, fill my heart with your most perfect, fervent, and unquenchable love, so that I may always thirst for you with all my heart, and that I may love you at all times, in all things, and above all things.

O most gracious Jesus, my God and all in all, I beg you, enlighten my heart to recognize, love, and carry out your good pleasure. Grant me perfect self-denial and self-surrender, so that I may completely abandon myself in every way, go out of myself, and surrender myself to all your good pleasure. Grant me that I may completely trust in your providence, receiving all things from your Hand; Receive all things from your hand with thanksgiving, and praise and bless you in all things. Grant, O gracious God, that all my life, at all times, I may dedicate and offer all the actions and powers of my body and soul, and all that I am and can do, to your praise, honor, and good pleasure. Amen.

Monday, February 2, 2026

Practicing Death: The “Seven Last Words” at Thalbach

The back-end of the Thalbach prayerbook (ÖNB Cod. 11750, 56v-60r) provides an early modern devotional adaptation of the “Seven Last Words” (Sieben Worte Christi am Kreuz), transformed into a death-bed meditation cycle. This is a localized, pastoralized, and affectively expanded version of a common text-type, rather than a “standard” translation of a single printed source. They all start from the biblical sequence (Luke, John, Matthew) but are freely paraphrased and expanded.

The tradition itself was extremely widespread. As a genre, the Seven Last Words meditation typos predates the Reformation and survives confessionalization pretty well intact, growing and adapting to local belief and its needs. The genre draws on at least three major late medieval/early modern currents. Like much of the Passion meditation literature in general, it promotes imaginative participation in a visually re-enacted passion scene, along with the attached emotional identification and afirst-person response that sees oneself as part of that broader narrative. It fits in too with other ars moriendi texts, in that it emphasizes a readiness for death along with a renunciation of “zeitliche” things. The penitent soul submits to God will, echoing--through an act of will--the Passion as a model (“into your hands I commend myself”). And, it fits with its late 16th century ethos, a time when structured death prayers and affective piety intermingled as a way of coaching the devout toward a particular kind of religiosity.

The Thalbach version—copied as an addition to the manuscript in a dubious scribal hand and bearing several signs of amateur copying (from letter forms to transcription errors)—is interesting for several reasons. (I give a provisional transcription of the Seventh Word at the end of this post for those interested.)

BIBLICAL ALLUSION: It is typical of post-1500 vernacular adaptations of this sort, in that it boasts a kind of biblical in-fill with a number of loose biblical quotations shaping its language and approach. For instance, the text integrates not just passion narrative, but scriptural allusion. For example, the end of the fifth word brings in the deer of Psalm 42:

  • darumb durstet mein Seel nach dir, dem Leben: unnd Gleich wie ein Zürsche eilet, Zu den Wasser brunen, Also Blomiget mein Seel nach dir, das du sie trenkhe mit dem siirssen kranckh de mer ewigen khlarheit, vnd sie behrtest vor dem hellischen durß in Ewigkheit, Amen

  • therefore my soul thirsts for you, the living word, and just as a deer hastens to the water springs, so my soul longs for you, that you may quench its thirst with the sweet drink of your eternal clarity, and preserve it from the hellish thirst in eternity. Amen.

  • (Psalm 42, NIV: As the deer pants for streams of water, so my soul pants for you, my God. 2 My soul thirsts for God, for the living God. When can I go and meet with God? 3 My tears have been my food day and night, while people say to me all day long, “Where is your God?”)

This text lives in a world shaped by the Psalm’s echo, a strong framing for affective contemplation. Such biblical saturation suggests a deeply grounded reader, someone who could “get” the allusions without citation or further prompting. To my eye, that speaks to Thalbach educational practices; sisters of whatever level were expected to know their psalter intimately.

FIRST PERSON FRAMING ON THE DEATHBED: The text, divided into seven parts, with each part on its own page-or-two, serves as a bit of a how-to guide to walk you through the final hours of life. That process demands a kind of penitential self-examination, common to early modern Catholicism. There is a strong first-person presence in this version of the Seven Last Words, and that is shaped around the actual act of dying, not just a meditation-on-death.

Death is a consistent presence: “meines Todts… Sterben… mein Leiden… meiner Seele… bereit zu sterben” (my death... dying... my suffering... my soul... ready to die). In case the text itself wasn’t a good enough pointer (and it clearly is), the rubric tells us so: den Sterbenden mensch Trostlich (Comforting the dying person). This is devotional literature aimed at actual dying, not general piety.

INTERIORITY: Almost every section moves quickly into a confessional self-assessment: As a sinner, a poor sinner, I recognize my sins, she posits repeated. This is commission, the things she has done that are wrong, but also omission: “ich … wenig guets gethan, darumb ich billich ewige Straffe (I have done little good, therefore I deserve eternal punishment.)

We are seeing here an individualistic interiorization of the need for forgiveness, not a communal experience of death. There’s no collective voice, and no institutional framing. We don’t have the sisters coming to the sound of the clapper; this is death as an act of self identity through a direct encounter, God to soul. It has a lot of parallels with the shift in how Bregenz memoria were constructed, to be honest, but that’s for another (and extensive) bit of writing.

SOCIAL ETHICS OF DYING: She may be considering her interior spiritual needs, but those needs are also manifest as the things she has done to others while in the world. In the Second Word, for instance, she ask forgiveness:

die ich beleidige, zu sünden verursacht habe (whom I have offended, and caused to sin)

So death is framed as a moment of social repair, not only private salvation.

MY TAKE-AWAY:

For me, this modest, messy text is a reminder of why these prayerbooks matter so much. Its theology is not expressed in polished argument, but in repetition, hesitation, and emotional insistence. It shows how the sisters were taught to inhabit their own deaths in advance—through scripture, through penitence, through acts of reconciliation. Read alongside Thalbach’s commemorative practices and memorial networks, it suggests that preparation for death was not only something done for others, but something carefully cultivated within the self. This small addition thus opens a window onto the inner work of memoria: the quiet, disciplined labor of learning how to die well.


DAS SIBENT WORT / THE SEVENTH WORD:

What follows is a provisional transcription and translation of the Seventh Word, offered to illustrate the tone and structure of the text rather than as a definitive edition. I have lightly normalized the German: vnnd = und, dir außgangen = dir ausgegangen; schopffung = Schöpfung, and so on.

60r das sibent wort
Herr Gott vnnd Vatter, Ich bin von
die außgangen, durch die schopf:
fung in dise welt, Nun aber muß
in alles was zeitlich ist, Er lasse
vnnd widr zu die komen in dem
ewigs reich, denn es nachet
die Stundt, vnd ist kost auß mit
meinem ellenden vergenkhlich
Leben, Doch bin vnuerzogt, den
mene seeligkheit stehet in deiner
handt, darein ich dir auch mein
Armen seel treulich wil be-
folchen haben Vnd bin berait zu
Sterben, Darumb Laß mich dir
aller Liebster vatter, Zu aller
Zeit beuolchen sein, vnd wie ich
dir utrån, er weckh nich wid
om Inngste, tag, mit denen
Ausser wollen dich ewigkhlich
zu Loben
The Seventh Word
Lord God and Father, I have come forth from you through creation into this world.
Now, however, I must leave behind
everything that is temporal
and return to you
in the eternal kingdom.
For the hour draws near, and
my wretched, perishable life
is soon at an end. Yet I am not afraid,
for my salvation rests in your
hand, into which I faithfully commend
my poor soul. And I am ready to die.
Therefore, let me, most beloved Father,
remain entrusted to you at all times.
And just as I place my trust in you,
do not raise me up again
on the Last Day among those who are rejected, but among those who are chosen to praise you eternally.

Saturday, January 17, 2026

A 16thc Segen for the Mass, Pt 2


The Thalbach Segen for the Mass

The first half of this Segen – which I posted about last week – establishes its logic through enclosure, accumulation, and analogy: the devotee commends herself into sacred realities, borrows the authority of the Mass, and maps Christ’s body onto her own as a form of protection. Part 2 intensifies this same logic, shifting from verbal placement to embodied action. What was established through words is now reinforced through gesture, orientation, and repetition, as the sign of the cross is deployed to surround the body, bind danger, and authorize protection in motion. 


PART TWO OF THE SEGEN, "HErr ich bevilch mich dir in alle die heillige wortt die alle Priieſter ſprech"  ÖNB Cod. 11750, fols. 21r-22v (Part 1 is transcribed and translated here). Division into segments reflects editorial assessments; bold is added to highlight structural repetition. Transcription and translation are CC-BY Cynthia Cyrus.

Beth ein vatter vnser vn̅ ein Aue mar[ia] 

           Pray an Our Father and a Hail Mary.

Das heïllig Gottes Creütz [REDCROSS] Jhesu christi seẏ heutt vor mir. [REDCROSS] Vnsers herrn creutz seẏ heutt hinder mir. Vnſers herrn creutz. [REDCROSS] ſei ob mir Vnſers herrn creutz [REDCROSS] sey heut zuͦ den ſeittenn neben mir. Ach Gott gesegne mich heut vnd Jmer bei dem heilligenn fron [REDCROSS] Creütz dagott die marter an leidt durch mich vund aller Chriſtenhait ·

The holy cross of God [REDCROSS] of Jesus Christ be before me today. [REDCROSS] Our Lord's cross be behind me today. Our Lord's cross [REDCROSS] be above me. Our Lord's cross [REDCROSS] be on my sides next to me today. Oh God, bless me today and forever by the holy [REDCROSS] cross, where God endured the suffering for me and all of Christendom.

Nur můs ich als wol geſegnet ſein als der Kelch unnd der wein den ein ieder Priester muß es das er die mass volbringen kan. [REDCROSS] Nur můs ich als war gesegnet sein, als des gutten hern Tobias ſun, do er in frembden landenn was [REDCROSS] Nur mus ich als war geſegnet sein, als dir heillige drei nagell / die Gott durch hend vnnd füess würden geſchlagen

I must be as well blessed as the chalice and the wine that every priest must have so that he can perform the Mass. I must be as truly blessed as the son of the good Lord Tobias, when he was in foreign lands. I must be as truly blessed as the three holy nails that God was struck with through his hands and feet.

Ich beüilch mich in die krafft vnd in die krafft wortt / da gott mensch inn ward. Ich beüilch mich in die fliessende bach vnd schwayss vnnd bluts, so vnnser lieber herr vergossenn hat. Ich beuil mich heut in die seligkeit ich armer sunder, vnd durch die krafft seines Lebendigen Sons gebe nedeiten tods. / Ich beuilch mich heutt in die seligkeit seines heilligen sacraments Ich fleuch heut vnder den schult vnnd vnder den frid, vnnd vnder dz heillig Creitz [22r] Das ſelber durch mich vnnd alle menſchen zuͦ einem Creutz gemacht hat Jch beuil mich heüt vnd allweg in die heillige Driualtigkeit vnſers herrnn Jeſu chriſti vnd in die heilige Senfftmuettigkeit Barmhertzigteit keuschheitt vnser lieben frawen Maria, vnd in die gemainſame aller heiligen.

I commend myself to the power and the word in which God became man. I commend myself to the flowing stream of sweat and blood that our dear Lord shed. I commend myself today to salvation, I poor sinner, and through the power of his living Son, grant me a blessed death. I commend myself today to the salvation of his holy sacrament. I flee today under the protection and under the peace, and under the holy cross which he himself has made into a cross for me and all people. I commend myself today and always to the Holy Trinity of our Lord Jesus Christ and to the holy gentleness, mercy, and chastity of our dear Lady Mary, and to the communion of all saints.

Dz creutz [REDCROSS] vnſers herrn Jeſu chriſti ſei heut mit mir Das [REDCROSS] Creutz vnsers lieben herrn verbind mir aller meiner feinden ſchwert. Das [REDCROSS] Creutz vnsers herrn eroffne mir alles güts Dz [REDCROSS] Creutz vnsers herrn neme von mir alles vbell vnd alle pein des ewigen tods. Nur [REDCROSS] geſegne mich der heillig ſegenn den gott vber sich ynnd alle menschen hatt gebem da gott ſelbs inn beſchaffenn wz.

The cross of our Lord Jesus Christ be with me today. The cross of our dear Lord bind the sword of all my enemies. The cross of our Lord open to me all good things. The cross of our Lord take from me all evil and all the pain of eternal death. May the holy blessing that God gave over himself and all people, in which God himself was created, bless me.

Ich beuil mich heut in die ſiben wort, die gott selbs ſprach an dem heilligen creütz. Ich beuil mich heut in den heilligen frid vnſers hern gesuchristi, der sei mir heut ein anfang vnd einausgang in allen meinen nötten, wo ich Jn der Welltt hinkör

I commend myself today to the seven words that God himself spoke on the holy cross. I commend myself today to the holy peace of our Lord Jesus Christ, may it be for me today a beginning and an end in all my needs, wherever I go in the world.

Nur gelegne mich heut der lieb herr Sannt Johannes in ſeiner keussigheitt. Nur geſegne mich der gut ſant Benedict vor Zauberei, diſe zwen haben gebet vnſern herrn Jeſum chriſtum, Welcher man oder fraw ſchmertzen hat, dz in ſeinem verdiennſt er geſundt werd. O Schmertz dich zerſtrew gott der Sun. O ſchmertz dich zerstrew gott der Heillig Gayſt. Jn dem Namenn gott des Vatters vnnd des Süns vnnd des heilligen Geists. Amen.

May the dear Lord Saint John bless me today in his chastity. May the good Saint Benedict bless me against sorcery; these two prayed to our Lord Jesus Christ, that whoever, man or woman, has pain, may be healed through his merit. O pain, may God the Son scatter you. O pain, may God the Holy Spirit scatter you. In the name of God the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit. Amen.


ASSESSMENT

Part 2 opens with formulaic prayer – an Our Father and a Hail Mary – and then immediately shifts register. The prayer stops asking and starts placing. What follows is no longer a petition addressed upward, but a sequence of directional statements that actively organize space around the speaker. Repeated invocations of “Das heilig Gottes Creutz … sey heut vor mir / hinder mir / ob mir / zu den seiten neben mir” (before me, behind me, above me, and to my sides) construct a six-directional enclosure, situating the devotee within a protective field defined by the cross.

This language is not metaphorical. It performs a spatial act. The cross is placed before and behind the body, above it, and on both sides; it creates a perimeter that surrounds rather than adorns. The red crosses marked in the manuscript are not ornamental flourishes, but operative cues. They prompt gesture, orientation, and repetition. They invite the speaker to action -- to trace the cross repeatedly in space, turning the prayer into enacted words that produce protection through kinetic movement.

In this sense, Part 2 takes up and extends the work already begun at the end of the first half of the prayer. There, the speaker mapped herself onto Christ’s body as a way of securing protection; here, that logic is expanded outward. Protection is no longer only anatomical or analogical but locational. The body is not simply aligned with Christ’s wounds or limbs, but physically enclosed within the sign of the cross itself, now rendered as a mobile defensive geometry.

This is characteristic Segen practice. Rather than cultivating inward reassurance, the prayer re-positions the body in sacred space. Safety is achieved not through reflection but through placement – through saying, marking, and standing within a configuration that has been declared protective. Like prayers before the image of Mary, the actions of the praying sister are integral to the prayer itself.

AUTHORIZATION THROUGH ANALOGY AND EQUIVALENCE

The prayer then pivots to a striking rhetorical strategy, signaled by the repeated formula “Nur muß ich als wol gesegnet sein als …” Rather than petitioning for blessing, the speaker asserts a claim to it through a series of carefully chosen comparisons. What follows is not metaphor but equivalence: the devotee aligns herself with persons and objects whose efficacy is already established.

Three such alignments structure this section. First, the speaker claims to be as well blessed as the chalice and the wine required for the priest to complete the Mass. Here, efficacy is functional and liturgical: these objects are blessed not because they are morally exemplary, but because without them the sacramental action cannot occur. Second, she likens herself to Tobias’ son, protected by the Angel Raphael while traveling in foreign lands. This comparison draws on narrative precedent, invoking a scriptural story in which divine protection accompanies movement, risk, and vulnerability. Third, she claims the blessing of the three holy nails of the Crucifixion, instruments rendered powerful through direct contact with Christ’s suffering body.

Taken together, these comparisons establish a logic of borrowed authority. The speaker does not present herself as worthy in her own right, nor does she wait for blessing to be conferred. Instead, she places herself on the same plane as liturgical vessels, biblical travelers, and relic-like instruments – things and figures already known to work. In doing so, the prayer authorizes lay access to protective power by grounding it in recognized sites of efficacy. Blessing here is not requested but claimed, secured through alignment with what has already proven capable of bearing and transmitting divine force.

SALVIC THINGS

The long middle section (Ich beüilch mich…) is a catalog of efficacious media:

  • the wort of the Incarnation
  • sweat, blood, and flowing fluids
  • the sacrament
  • peace
  • the cross
  • the Trinity
  • Marian virtues
  • the community of saints

This is not redundant piety. It is strategic stacking. Each item is something that:

  • has already worked (historically or liturgically)
  • can be entered or taken refuge under
  • and can be carried by the speaker.

The repeated ich bevilch mich performs self-placement again and again. The speaker repeatedly moves themselves into zones of protection, as though tightening a net. Part one of the prayer set up her spiritual safety; her active remembrance of these holy things thus reinforces that zone.

The cross, of course, has a special status, and the next unit of the Segen re-activates it, showing its kinetic and temporal power through verb choice. It:

  • binds enemies’ swords
  • opens all good
  • removes evil and eternal death

The cross operates metaphorically as weapon, key, and filter. This is apotropaic language in its strongest form: harm is actively restrained, not merely avoided.

COMPLETENESS IN TIME AND IN BINARIES

By invoking the seven last words spoken from the cross, peace as both Anfang and Ausgang (beginning and end), and movement “wherever I go in the world,” the prayer works deliberately to close all remaining gaps. Time is framed from beginning to end, speech is completed in silence, motion is paired with rest, pain with healing, and present vulnerability is extended forward to encompass future death. These paired terms are not incidental but systematic: the Segen seeks to leave no interval, condition, or threshold unguarded. What emerges is a prayer oriented toward completeness rather than intensity, one that aims not at a single moment of relief but at comprehensive coverage across the temporal and existential spectrum.

To this, she adds the saints as targeted intercessors. John, whose chastity aligns with bodily integrity; Benedict, who provides protection against sorcery, mark her world as one of pragmatic sanctity. Saints are invoked for what they do, not who they are. The direct address to pain (O Schmertz…) completes the transition from prayer to command. Pain is not asked to leave. It is told to disperse – twice, under Trinitarian authority.


THE SEGEN AS PRAYER ACT

Taken together, the second half of this prayer is neither contemplative nor primarily petitionary. It is not oriented toward extended reflection or interior cultivation, but toward use. The prayer functions instead as a ritual technology of protection, assembled from spatial enclosure, authorized comparison, accumulated salvific matter, spoken command, and repeated acts of self-placement. What gives it force is not doctrinal exposition but correct enactment: familiar words spoken in the right order, gestures traced in space, and authoritative figures and objects invoked because they are already known to work.

Read in this way, the prayer aligns closely with recent scholarship that emphasizes the everyday, practice-oriented character of Segen. Ulrike Wagner-Rau, writing in Segen, characterizes blessings as rituals that are “unverbrüchlich angesehen” not because they offer explanation, but because they provide reliable ways of navigating ordinary life through repeated action. Christopher Spehr’s contribution to the same volume likewise underscores the diversity and adaptability of late medieval blessing practices, situating Segen firmly within lived religious routines rather than at the margins of official devotion. To make the point more directly: for our Thalbach sister to be enacting her Segen during and in the presence of the Mass is every bit as standard a sacred and parallel act as is the spoken delivery of requiem masses at a side altar underneath the Fronmass. Simultaneity has its own kind of sacred power.

Although he deals with an earlier 12th to 14th century repertoire of such Segen, Derek A. Rivard’s Blessing the World helps clarify what is at stake. His study shows that blessings were shaped by lay needs and aspirations and that their protective focus complemented the Mass’s role in sustaining communal order and integrity. I would argue that the Thalbach Segen operates in precisely this register. Drawing on familiar narratives, liturgical forms, and bodily practices, it translates shared Christian knowledge into ritual action calibrated for vulnerability – illness, danger, movement, and the prospect of death.

What emerges, then, is not an alternative to theology, but a way of living it. This Segen does not seek to explain suffering or risk; it offers a means of addressing them through repeated, embodied practice. Anchored in the Mass yet usable beyond it, the prayer extends ecclesial protection into the rhythms of everyday life. For the Thalbach sisters, and for others who prayed in similar ways, safety was not a matter of abstract belief but of learned habit: something done, enacted, and carried forward through words and gestures that had already proven their worth. At Thalbach, such habits were cultivated collectively – through shared prayerbooks, repeated attendance at the parish Mass, and the parallel rhythms of memoria and devotion – so that protection was not merely personal, but explicitly embedded in the sisters’ communal practice.


WORKS CITED

Cynthia Cyrus, "Praying Before the Image of Mary: Nuns’ Prayerbooks and the Mapping of Sacred Space" Religions 16, no. 10 (2025): 1277. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel16101277, https://www.mdpi.com/3532324

Martin Leuenberger (ed.) Segen. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2015.

See especially Ulrike Wagner-Rau and her discussion of everyday rituals, “Unverbrüchlich angesehen – Der Segen in praktisch-theologischer Perspektive,” 187-210, here p. 194.

In the same volume, Christopher Spehr addresses the diversity of blessings in late medieval practice, and their re-evaluation in the Reformation; “Sengespraxis und Segenstheologie in der Christentumsgeschickte,” 135-164.

Derek A. Rivard, Blessing the World: Ritual and Lay Piety in Medieval Religion (Washington DC: Catholic U of America Press, 2009)

Note: This post presents a working transcription, translation, and preliminary analysis in advance of a planned journal article.

What does HMML sound like?

HMML has for me a distinct array of sounds. I thought a little Tell-and-Show might capture some untold aspects of my fellowship time. F...