HMML has for me a distinct array of sounds. I thought a little Tell-and-Show might capture some untold aspects of my fellowship time.
First, the bells. Being located abbey-adjacent, there is both an impressive sight-line and, when I do emerge into the outdoor, the wonderful bell-peal that tells the hours. As my friend Mozhdeh says, we learn to listen to the bells to figure out time of day. It’s very “historical clock” in atmosphere. Bells are enough of an unusual feature for me as a country-dweller back home that they always catch my attention when I’m outside enough to hear them.
Second, the sound of autumn leaves. The campus is just COVERED with trails, and during the shoulder season, I got between 3 and 7 miles of walking in every day. The place is just beautiful, and I would walk/run before breakfast, at lunch, and/or at the 4p hour. An obvious destination is the trail to the chapel – if you hit it just right, you get the glinting light of stained glass.
Or you could go on the wetlands path, a gorgeous and partly pontoon-path through the wetlands out by the freeway and back up along the ridge toward campus.
But my favorite was to head out on the less well maintained trails back-of-beyond and just walk along. Lake, or hill, or glacial deposit rock, and trees, trees, so many trees. Plus the lovely lovely sound of the deep bed of leaves that covered the trail. Swishy-swashy, swishy-swashy, swishy-swashy:
And then there was the part that drove my days, and many a night as well. And that’s the sound of the microfilm equipment. So if you’ve never seen a microfilm, imagine a bunch of tiny photos on a strip of cellulose. An image, then a wee bit of black space, then the next image, and so on. By pulling the cellulose strip through the glass plates, you can look at each page of manuscript in turn.
Well, the first couple of times I turned on the new and fancy digital microfilm-viewing machines, I was nearly terrified by the loud and mechanical start up sounds. At first, you have to turn on the viewing platform itself:
Then after that’s all resolved, you have to hook the reader to the viewer, and that involves another set of mechanical grinding noises:
At the end of the day, what you get is the chance to see your manuscript images, enlarge them, forward them, back them up, and generally manipulate the object to get at the meat of the manuscript’s content. Given legal agreements between manuscript-owner and HMML, many (nearly all) of the things I consulted can’t be duplicated without writing along for permissions, so a lot of my time was spent keyboarding in the texts that will matter to the chapter I’m writing.
I didn’t spend all day in my carrel; I also browsed the absolutely amazing collection of library catalogs – a destination in its own right where you can just pull it off the shelf instead of waiting the three weeks for interlibrary loan (ahem). At other times, I ran to ground concordance leads in the impressive collection of liturgical and theological writings in the Alcuin library. But the best part of the day was almost always that moment when the high-pitch of microfilm readiness meant another manuscript was ready for viewing.
Though the sounds of Halloween were pretty impressive too…
For all the time I spent “inside my brain,” I did a surprising amount of listening at HMML. Bells told me what hour it was -- but it was the microfilm reader that regularly told me it was time to get back to work.
Funding This post was brought to you by the Carpenter Fellowship at HMML. I’m grateful to HMML and its staff for making this such a wonderfully supportive place to work!
YOU MIGHT ALSO BE INTERESTED IN
A Day In the Life of a Carpenter Fellow at HMML. You’ve heard what a fellowship day sounds like. Here’s what one looks like, from my microfilm carrel and lunchtime walks to the Franciscan sisters’ vows that sent me down a midweek rabbit hole.
Smells and bells? Just bells!. What did bells announce in late medieval Bregenz? Come listen in on the memorial services donors paid for, and see which sense their remarkably detailed instructions leave unmentioned.
I’ve been thinking
about that as I’ve hung about in Northern climes; I may be hard at
it in my library research (as a HMML Carpenter Fellow; more on that
in other posts), but my weekends are filled with new-to-me
experiences.
To take an example
(or two): I worked a prairie refurbishment day up by Poplar Grove IL
at Kinnikinnick Creek Forest Preserve and Conservation area,
Caledonia IL last weekend, and, oh, was it lovely!
Often the tasks there are to cut back invasives, but here at the end
of the season it was time to collect seed for next year’s new
patches of rewilding lands. So a group of half-a-dozen volunteers
went out on a Saturday for a supervised “pick” on the
soon-to-be-closed-for-winter patch of prairie at the conservation
area. When I say supervised, I speak as the novice; everyone else had
definitely been out there before, and most of them were professional
or quasi-professional preservationists of one type or another.
For our morning’s
labor, we were collecting two major types of seeds -- pagoda plant
(in three species: downy wood mint, hairy wood mint, and horse-mint
bee-balm) and silky wild rye. Pagoda plant really does look a set of
piled pagodas on a stalk. We started off just wandering the field up
on the hillside, but once someone had actually found a plant, we
grouped up for a mini-lesson in plant identification, and then each
person took off on their own wander to play “I spy.”
Once we started
finding the plants, an abundance mentality set in. They grow in
patches, so if you find one set of seeds, you usually find between 20
and 50 sets of seeds. Of course, as good conservationists we took the
top half so the rest could re-seed for next year. Caring for the
local prairie patch is priority number one, leaving enough seed for
new plants, but also for the animals that need to overwinter.
I actually did
not-half-bad on the hunt-and-find for pagoda plant; I was mostly
responsible for downy wood mint, but turned up a great deal of
horse-mint bee-balm as a result. (Those seeds went in the other
bucket so I didn’t get to count them as MY totals!) Still, every
once in a while I would find a patch of the downy wood mint, enough
so that I noticed that I had used my bending over muscles a good bit
while out on the hillside!
The silky wild rye grew in a giant and quite obvious patch, as you
may have noticed in the picture above. So harvesting there was a
matter of pick a large handful, drop it in a bucket, pick another
large handful, drop it in a bucket. Rinse and repeat. We had such
abundance that we wound up having to combine buckets to make way for
the seed bag, designed to hold about 40 lbs of animal feed. We got
that bag more than half-way full, so it definitely felt like success!
By the end of that
second picking, I understood the idea that one could put in an order
for “75 lbs of such-and-so seed” and the main office wouldn’t
actually blanch at the request. I also learned that every year, they
obtain a selection of seeds, and those go into targeted
refurbishments elsewhere. Every little bit helps.
Listening, I though
I'd notice wind and birdsong, and it was certainly there, but I found
myself instead drawn to the people telling stories -- the community
they'd built, their friendships, their stories of leadership and not
wanting leadership on firelines, and restorative burns and the ways
in which the newbies (me?!!!) interact, particularly in "those"
moments, and motivations and the ways that people respond to nature.
About the building where during winter months our seeds would be
cleaned and further sorted and prepared for next use.
I wasn't listening
to nature, I was listening to nature being managed. And that, for me,
was pretty cool. The prairie’s abundance had people behind it,
people with knowledge and friendships and stories worth hearing.
Of course, I mainly
took pictures of flowers instead of the dead stalks of mint plants,
so my flower pictures from that trip are better. Oh well.
Common Blue Wood Aster, Aromatic Aster, and Coreopsis
What the flower pictures indicate – what our labors show – what a
morning of close inspection taught me – is that the nature of the
prairie is in its abundance. That abundance is not to be measured
just plants-per-foot, but in kinds
of plants-per-foot. Of course there were grasses, and sedges,
and little vines which seemed to want to trip you. But as Jessie, our
leader, gave us our instructions, she taught us to use the shapes of
things – to look for a pile of pagodas, or for the waving stalks of
rye – to see one shape among many, so that its shape
could go on to re-seed new plots of land with similar diversity when
the time comes.
Isn’t that a sweet meta-lesson on how the earth should be?
And
speaking of earth, the other thing we did was to attend
E(ART)H, a “Land Art” show at Nature at the Confluence, South
Beloit, IL. Nature at the Confluence used to be a dump, for decades,
with just piles and piles of debris on top of once had been an
important tribal meeting ground. (Says something about respect and
its lack, eh?) The land has been reclaimed, and a community park made
through extensive efforts. There are winding trails and an
interpretive center with picnic areas.
The idea behind the
show was for the artists to use found materials placed within the
context of this reclaimed land to make statements about the
connection we all have to the earth around us. It was really well
attended; in the three hours we were there I counted more than 130
people, and it had been running all day (including while we were out
doing our prairie refurbishment). The opening included live music and
performance – including a movement choir – as well as remarks by
the artists.
Each of the artists
had chosen a different array of materials and a different array of
techniques. They were linked by eco-awareness; positioning their work
in the landscape was a choice, and the guided tour took us variously
along stream-bank, into the shaded woods, and around the circle of
mown land as it edged up against prairie grasses. Place is part of
art’s perception, and each artist spoke to why this spot – the
fallen log which landed in the crook of the tree; a favored spot
where the murmur of water joined up with the mosaic flower image to
create a fibonacian meditation; the shaded nook where creation seems
to both spring up from the earth and come down from the trees above.
The other reality is that art can become a way of asking us to think
about place in new ways. “Mother Bison” by Jenny Mathews, for
instance, creates the image of a bison but is made out of things like
willow branches and grapevine, with prairie grasses and gourds for
eyes. It is held together by string. Jenny placed it so that it is
emerging from the taller grasses, which seemed particularly symbolic
given both the history of the landscape around it and the history of
the bison and its reintroduction.
Fun aside: the bison is in part a meat animal, and bison ranching for
food is integrally tied up with its successful management, yet
ranchers and indigenous peoples have very different views of how the
animal should be treated. “Bison”-branded meat in the store is
good for the animal because ranching has maintained biodiversity
among the herds; we are still at the point where more animals is
better for the species.
And yet, “bison”
then becomes a ladened term, associated more with what can be read as
exploitative culture. “Buffalo,” though colloquially familiar to
us in the USA, is technically not
the right word for these animals, because, as wikipedia taught me,
bison are yak relatives, genus Bos,
and buffalo are in two genera, the African Syncerusand the Asiatic Bubalus.
All kinds of species in this world, eh?
Anyhoo, we have tended to use the misnomer “buffalo” for these
majestic animals (“Where the buffalo roam, and the deer and the
antelope play…”), and so the label “bison” is doing some
heavy lifting in the world these days. Enough so that when Jenny
approached members of a local tribe, they at first shrugged her off,
because she was using the technically correct term “bison” and
they thought that stood in for a way of thinking about the animal.
She now leads with the term “buffalo,” and has been much more
successful at connecting with them out of shared philosophy of what
these majestic creatures mean for us and our mutual – if not always
amicable – history.
Jessie Crow Mermel,
“Ecology of a Breath” uses the echo of dendritic patterns with
their branching structures – in the hand, in the lungs, in the
nerves, and in the river systems. She used images on cloth, but also
incorporated moss lungs, since moss actually put out more O2
than trees do! “Patterns,” she says “can serve as a mirror and
remind us how deeply we are interwoven with the rest of the Earth.”
Plus, I have a particular affection for Jessie’s work since she’d
been the Person In Charge of the morning’s Prairie work. It brought
a real sense of the nature (pun intended) of community.
The artistic statement used to advertise the exhibit seemed in
keeping with the spirit of the weekend: “Our collective goal is to
spark wonder, acknowledge eco-anxiety, and inspire new connections.”
“Spark wonder” is a phrase I might ordinarily pass over in an
exhibit announcement. This time, though, I’d spent the morning
discovering how much there really was to find in a patch of prairie,
and the afternoon discovering how many ways artists could ask us to
look at reclaimed ground. Wonder had acquired both very particular
and very memorable shapes.
It had also come with something to do.
Learn a plant, gather seed, leave enough behind for an envisioned
future. Listen to an artist explain why a piece belongs beside this
stream or among these grasses. I can’t claim that a Saturday
settled my eco-anxiety, but it did give me a few useful places to put
my attention—and, for part of the day, my hands. My bending-over
muscles have registered their opinion too.
Soundscape compositions, Chicago style: What happens when art invites us to experience a familiar place differently? Two Chicago installations—including a composition heard among the ferns of Lincoln Park Conservatory—explore how sound, surroundings, and our own movements shape what we notice.
Listening to the Birds: Bird calls can tell us what is happening around us, if we learn to hear their differences. Jon Young’s What the Robin Knows offers ways to develop that attention, from recognizing alarm calls to noticing how our own passage changes the sounds of the woods.
The silence of the woods is full of noise: Streams burble, crickets chirp, and small animals rustle through the leaves—so why do we remember the woods as silent? This reflection explores how identifying unfamiliar sounds can turn apparent quiet into a comforting sense of the life around us.
If you think about it, pandemic music is not always about remembering. Sometimes it is about not remembering. Or at least not staring straight at the thing that threatens to take over the entire field of vision.
In my last post on pandemic music, I wrote about “We Don’t Talk About COVID” as cultural amnesia set to music: a funny song about the strange collective work of not talking about the very thing everyone was living through. This post sits beside that one, but I wanted to shift the emphasis from forgetting to distraction.
Distraction has a bad reputation. We tend to treat it as avoidance, superficiality, scattered attention, or moral failure. But in pandemic culture, distraction can also be care. It can create connection across distance. It can give people a way to process fear without naming fear directly. It can make time pass. It can keep the mind from circling endlessly around death, exposure, testing, transmission, quarantine, hospitalization, and all the ordinary logistics of trying to live through a crisis.
That does not mean distraction is innocent. It can help people survive. But on the flip side, it can also help societies stop noticing what they have decided not to change. That double function is what makes pandemic music interesting to me.
Humor is a way of making contact
One of the great early-pandemic genres was the parody song. Not polished comedy, exactly. More like: a familiar song, a shared situation, a webcam, a kitchen, a window, a joke about toilet paper or quarantine hair or the sudden weirdness of homebound life.
Chris Mann’s “Hello (from the Inside),” an Adele parody, is such a good example because its joke is structurally simple. Everyone already knows the emotional architecture of Adele’s “Hello”: distance, longing, melodrama, the impossible reach across separation. The parody barely needs to do anything before the old emotional machinery starts running in a new key. “Hello from the inside” is funny because it is obvious, and it is obvious because everyone suddenly understood the inside as a shared condition.
That kind of humor depends on recognizability. The viewer needs to know the original song, but also the situation: the isolation, the screen-mediated social life, the newly theatrical domestic interior. The window is not just scenery. It is the pandemic stage.
The Kiffness’s “Tequila,” redone by saying “Corona” instead, works differently. It is almost aggressively minimal. How little does a parody need in order to become funny? Apparently, not much. A single word-substitution can be enough when the cultural context does the rest of the work.
This is one of the strange efficiencies of pandemic humor. A song can be very small because the shared world is doing so much of the setup.
Thank you to my students for surfacing these particular examples, but as most of us remember, such parodies exist by the hundreds, and were broadly circulated, and “good ones” got hundreds of thousands of views, if not always the millions of Shirley Șerban or the Marsh family’s take on “One Day More.” “One more day all on my phone; one more selfie of me glaring.” Indeed.
Humor helps process fear, but it does not remove it
There is a reason so many of these songs hover near anxiety. “My Corona Home,” “Anti-bacterial Girl,” “Stayin’ Inside,” “Quarantine” parodies (like this or this or this), TikTok dances, handwashing songs, and endlessly circulated musical jokes all belong to a world in which people were trying to keep fear at a livable distance.
Humor did not mean people were not afraid. It meant fear had found a social form.
That distinction matters. In a crisis, funny songs are not just relief from seriousness. They are one way seriousness becomes shareable. A joke makes the feeling portable. A parody turns a private panic into something one can send to a friend. “This is us,” the link says. Or, “I hate that this is us.” Or, “I cannot believe this is us, but here we are.”
That is why pandemic humor often feels both silly and documentary. The joke records the room. The joke captures the mood of the room. Sometimes the joke is the room: the living room, the kitchen, the bedroom, the inside of a house suddenly forced to contain school, work, exercise, entertainment, worship, boredom, fear, family life, and the news.
Boccaccio already knew this
None of this is as new as it felt.
The Decameron is one of the great literary monuments to plague distraction. Its frame is familiar: seven young women and three young men flee plague-stricken Florence and pass the time with stories, songs, dances, conversation, gardens, meals, and a carefully organized social world. Boccaccio’s young people are not pretending plague does not exist. The frame depends on plague. But within that frame, they build a life where the mind can do something other than remain fixed on sickness and death.
What strikes me now is how musical that life is. The frame does not merely say, “They told stories.” It gives us a world of canzonets sung for delectation, dances after meals, songs with instruments, walking, gardens, games, and the rituals of taking turns. Music appears not as a decorative extra, but as part of the structure by which a small group preserves itself.
One could describe that as escapism. But that seems too thin. It is also social regulation. It is affective hygiene. It is time management. It is community-making. It is a way of keeping fear from becoming the only available form of attention.
Read carefully, the pattern hard to miss: in the Decameron, entertainments outnumber explicit disease references. There are songs, dances, walks, instruments, prayers, games, and repeated gestures of sociability; plague is the enclosing condition, but not always the named content. The disaster is everywhere, which is precisely why it does not have to be mentioned every minute.
Medieval doctors also knew this, which is frankly unnerving
Medieval and early modern plague advice often recommended what we might now call mood management. Don’t dwell on death. Avoid melancholy. Seek pleasant company. Hear pleasant things. Spend time in gardens. Use songs, stories, and delightful things that bring comfort.
That advice can sound absurd from a modern medical perspective. Songs do not stop Yersinia pestis. Pleasant stories do not replace public health. But the underlying observation is not foolish: fear is not neutral. Attention is not neutral. Sound is not neutral. A world saturated with death bells, offices for the dead, sickbed reports, rumors, and morbid talk can become its own kind of environment.
When a fourteenth-century physician recommends songs and minstrelsy, he is not inventing Spotify’s “calm” playlists, exactly. But he is recognizing a problem modern listeners know very well: when the mind is trapped in a loop, sound can help change the loop.
During COVID, many people did something similar with the tools at hand. They made playlists for baking, cleaning, work-from-home, sleep, calm, sadness, and background companionship. They learned TikTok dances. They layered up sea shanties (or even better the Wellerman version with Kermit the Frog). They joined virtual ensembles. They watched people they did not know make music from bedrooms and kitchens and stairwells. The point was not always aesthetic excellence. Often the point was, simply, to make time habitable.
Distraction as musicking
Christopher Small’s idea of “musicking” is useful here because it shifts attention away from music as an object and toward music as relationship. Music is not only organized sound. It is also the people taking part, the social arrangements, the imagined relationships, the model of the world the performance proposes.
That helps explain why so many pandemic musical artifacts are not especially interesting if treated only as compositions. A TikTok dance with a parent in the kitchen is not analytically rich because of harmonic invention. Sea Shanty TikTok is not interesting only because of the tune. A virtual orchestra is not moving only because of repertoire.
They matter because of the relationships they stage.
A family learns a dance together. A stranger adds a bass line to another stranger’s melody. Cellists clap three times to synchronize their separate rooms into one performance. A parody singer turns isolation into a joke thousands of people recognize. A country singer names what it feels like to be “six feet apart.” A joke song about quarantine becomes a tiny public square.
Distraction, in this sense, is not solitary. Even when it happens alone, it imagines a set of relationships.
Comfort, memory, and the danger of moving on
But here is the problem: the same musical forms that help people endure crisis can also help them move past it too quickly.
That was the tension in “We Don’t Talk About COVID.” The song was funny because it captured exactly how adaptation felt from the inside. But it was unsettling because adaptation also meant normalization. Half the school has COVID, so pack the lunch. Guidelines changed, so keep moving. Exposure became ordinary. Confusion became ordinary. The song made that weirdness audible.
Distraction songs can do something similar. They help us survive the immediate moment, but they may also document the moment when survival quietly becomes “normal.” Baking playlists. Cleaning playlists. Work-from-home playlists. Family dances. Sea shanties. Quarantine parody. These are not trivial artifacts. They show how quickly people began building livable routines inside unlivable conditions.
That is not a criticism. It may even be the most human thing about them. I don’t know about you, but distraction songs were certainly part of my email economy during the height of “safer at home.” And I looked forward to them, and even contributed to a Pomona College glee-club reunion Danny Boy. (Nostalgia for Covid quarantine, now that’s a weirdness!)
But it is worth asking what happened to those routines afterward. Did they become memory? Nostalgia? Embarrassment? Digital clutter? Evidence? Did they help us process what we were living through, or did they help us defer processing it?
The joke is also an archive
One reason I keep circling pandemic humor is that it preserves things official records do not. Public health documents tell us about policies, recommendations, mortality, testing, quarantine, and institutional response. Parody songs tell us how those policies felt in the kitchen.
They record the absurdity of insufficient information. They record the pressure to remain cheerful. They record the mismatch between official guidance and lived reality. They record the shrinking of the world to a house, a screen, a delivery box, a phone notification, a playlist, a meme, a family video, a familiar song rewritten for unfamiliar circumstances.
This is also why pandemic humor should not be dismissed as mere distraction. “Mere” is doing too much work there. Distraction may be one of the ways in which a culture documents crisis without becoming overwhelmed by it. The joke allows us to approach the scary thing. The parody creates sufficient distance. The borrowed tune holds the feeling steady long enough to look at it.
Or, to put it another way: sometimes the way we avoid looking directly at something becomes the best evidence of what we could not bear to see.
What distraction knows
Pandemic distraction knows that fear is exhausting.
It knows that people need rhythm, repetition, jokes, songs, stories, dances, gardens, windows, screens, and other people.
It knows that the mind cannot live indefinitely at the pitch of emergency.
It knows that music is not always memorial, protest, worship, or art. Sometimes music is a pressure valve. Sometimes it is a bridge. Sometimes it is the thing you send to someone else because you cannot quite say, “I am scared,” but you can say, “This made me laugh.”
That does not make it less serious. It may make it more so.
Because in the end, pandemic music does not only show us what people remembered. It also shows us how they got through the long, liminal hours in the shade of crisis.
Some examples of medieval medical advice in the face of plague:
Listen to "songs, stories, and melodies" (Anon 5: 390)
Listen to "comforting talk, pleasing songs, and sweetly harmonious sounds"; (Anon 6: 322, 336)
“Hear pleasant things and attractive stories” (Giovanni di Donde, ca. 1350)
“…make use of songs and minstrelsy and other pleasurable tales without tiring yourselves out, and all the delightful things that bring anyone comfort…” (Tommaso di Dino del Garbo, d. 1370)
“Let us rejoice and delight in melodies, songs, stories and similar delights.“ (Salamanca, 1515)
In our medievalism discussions this
semester, we’ve often asked a deceptively simple question: what
does it mean to “use” the medieval past? Sometimes the past is
reconstructed. Sometimes it is stylized, or put to a political
agenda.
And sometimes it
becomes something stranger: a set of sonic materials that can be
rearranged, fragmented, and reimagined.
Alfred Schnittke’s
Minnesang (1981) belongs very much in that last category.
Rather than reconstructing medieval song, Schnittke treats it almost
like archaeological fragments – pieces of melody, pieces of language,
pieces of texture that can be layered together into something
new.
What he tells us is that the past can be fully present, and yet sound
nothing like the past at all.
Before looking at how the piece works, it helps
simply to hear it.
Stefan
Parkman and the Danish
National Symphony Choir ℗ 1992 Chandos Records
Alfred Schnittke
and the Past
Alfred Schnittke (1934–1998) was one of
the most distinctive composers of the late Soviet period. His music
is often associated with what he called polystylism. He enjoyed the
mix-and-mingle of different genres’ conventions, with Renaissance
and Romantic language butting up against popular music styles, in a
vertiginous swirl of sound. As he put it,
“The goal of
my life is to unify serious music and light music, even if I break my
neck in doing so.”
His life was complicated by the
fractious and often oppressive cultural environment of the late
Soviet Union. During the Brezhnev era (1964–1982), artistic life
was shaped by political surveillance, ideological expectations, and a
leadership culture that prized stability over reform. Schnittke
himself experienced travel bans after abstaining from a Composers’
Union vote in 1980, and Minnesang was created at exactly that moment in his career. As a student of
Shostakovich, the question of politics’ potential influence on his
personal safety, let alone his musical reception, must surely have
been on his mind.
At the same time, he cultivated
an unusually deep relationship with the musical past. As a teenager
studying in Vienna in 1946, he later recalled a key and abiding
insight that was to influence his musical choices throughout his
life:
“Every moment there was a link in the historical
chain… the past represented a world of ever-present ghosts.”
That
sense of the past as ever-present becomes crucial for our
understanding of Minnesang.
The Piece: Minnesang (1981)
Schnittke
wrote Minnesang for 52
vocal parts, dividing the choir at times into dozens of independent
lines. The work draws on around twenty medieval German songs,
including material by:
Walther
von der Vogelweide
Neidhart
von Reuental
Wolfram
von Eschenbach
Heinrich
von Meissen
the
Monk of Salzburg
Yet Schnittke insisted that
he was not “composing” with these songs in the traditional sense. Rather,
he took a mosaicist’s approach:
“I
set the task to limit myself with only montage work without changing
any note of these songs.” (Schnittke
Program Notes, as quoted in Smirnov)
Even
the texts themselves are treated differently than one might expect.
The Middle High German language, largely opaque to modern listeners,
becomes part of the sonic texture, transformed,
as Schnittke claims, into simple phonemes
which help to create a
particular mood.
In
other words, the medieval material becomes sound matter.
What Is Schnittke’s Medievalism Doing?
This piece
belongs to a broader cluster of works in which Schnittke explored
spirituality and historical memory, including:
Requiem (1975)
Der Sonnengesang des Franz von Assisi (1976)
Symphony No. 2 “St. Florian” (1979)
Minnesang (1981)
Faust Cantata (1983)
Scholars sometimes frame this group as exploring tensions between
intuition and rationality, or what Zhanna Lehmann calls
gnosis – direct experiential insight rather than theoretical
knowledge. All of the works have medieval(ist) themes, and all were
written before his formal conversation in 1985. At one level, these
could be seen as an exploration of faith. At another, they are also
a dabbling in what history means to the present day.
That
perspective matters for Minnesang, because the piece does not
attempt to reconstruct medieval music historically. Instead, it asks
what happens when medieval fragments become objects of
contemplation.
Seeing the Music
Because the work involves so many
voices and overlapping layers, it can be hard to hear the structure
on first listening. This gave me a good excuse to learn a bit about
spectrograms, which show sound visually:
bright dense regions = many voices / louder passages
thin bands = fewer voices or sustained tones
vertical streaks = consonants, rhythmic entrances, or sudden dynamic
changes
Spectrogram generated in Sonic Visualiser; max frequency set to 6000 Hz
The spectrogram makes the piece’s
structure unusually easy to see: expansions appear as widening bands
of color, while the exploratory passages show thinner textures in
which individual melodic fragments briefly emerge.
Structural Overview of Schnittke’s Minnesang
I combined my
assessment from Sonic Visualiser with my own close listening to
generate the analysis provided here. (This assessment draws on
acoustical markers, not score analysis.)
Time
Layer
Label
0:00
STRUCTURE
Intro w/canon
1:57
STRUCTURE
X (melodic/textural exploration)
1:57
EVENT
fragments of tunes
3:24
EVENT
contrary motion
3:42
STRUCTURE
first build
3:42
EVENT
sudden reduced texture
4:54
STRUCTURE
Y (melodic/textural exploration)
4:54
EVENT
rising
7:22
EVENT
unison
7:53
STRUCTURE
full texture
7:53
EVENT
blocks of sound
10:51
EVENT
pile up
11:39
STRUCTURE
climax
11:59
EVENT
start collapse
13:11
STRUCTURE
last build
13:11
EVENT
reduce then build
13:53
STRUCTURE
Z (melodic/textural exploration)
13:53
EVENT
fragments of tunes
15:20
STRUCTURE
END
An assessment of Schnittke’s
structure
I.
Introduction (0:00–1:57)
0:00
— Intro w/canon 1:56
— “X”
The
opening establishes the material contrapuntally, with fragments
surfacing within a relatively transparent texture. There is an
emphasis on paired voices in canon, but in the context of a thick
texture in which individual gestures retain attention only briefly
before dissolving back into the mass of sound. If you look at just
the first 90 seconds, you can see these canons clearly:
Short
fragments will start in a lower voice, to be paired directly with a
voice slightly higher in the texture. These two-voice groupings are
more prominent than the (softer and higher) voices which sing
aligned, also in a fragmented, disconnected smattering of
phrase-fragments.
Gradually,
the texture widens out – a pattern that will repeat twice more over
the course of the piece – in order to set up a new section (“X”)
devoted to exploration of fragments of the various Minnesang tunes.
Here
the choir begins to play with melodic fragments more explicitly.
Individual gestures emerge momentarily before giving way to others,
producing a shifting field of brief melodic appearances rather than
sustained thematic statements.
Exploratory
Cycle 2 (3:42-7:22)
3:42
— texture widens
out 4:54
— Section Y:
exploration of melodies: rising
melody at first, later
“Ich habe” (5:26); and a dotted rhythm melody (6:26) each emerge
briefly for attention
7:22
— unison reset
After this section’s expansion of tessitura, this cycle moves
through a series of fragments, some with surprisingly clear profiles.
It ends by drawing to a unison, which acts as a structural pivot,
resetting the texture before a broader expansion.
Central Expansion and Climax
(7:53-11:59)
7:53
— full texture, with blocks of sound 10:51 —
accumulation begins
11:39
— climax 11:59 — start of collapse
From the unison, Schnittke quickly
rebuilds the choral mass. The texture expands through alternating
blocks of sound, shifting between low and high registers and
increasing in dynamic intensity. The spectrum gradually
widens – particularly upward – before the addition of a low pulsating
foundation.
At 10:51 a more continuous accumulation
begins, leading to a sustained and prolonged climax centered around
11:39. At this point the spectrogram shows the maximum spectral
saturation of the entire piece: full tessitura with sustained soprano
intensity.
Dissolution and reconfiguration
(11:59-15:20)
11:59
— thinning / collapse 13:11 — reduction
then renewed build-out of the texture
13:53
— Section Z: medieval lyrics re-emerge as a focus
After the climax the texture thins but
retains strong harmonic bands. Rather than dissolving entirely, the
music reorganizes itself, preparing one final gesture: a final rapid
expansion of the texture leading into a renewed lyrical exploration
of the Minnesang fragments.
This final cycle might perhaps be
considered a coda, but to me it serves more as a reframing, turning
back to those earlier exploratory sections, reconsidering what these
medieval fragments can do for us as pieces of sound.
Schnittke’s compositional process
Just a few observations, and those
derived largely from listening rather than from such things as
sketches and interviews:
CANON: First, several scholars,
including Mark Jennings (2002), note that the work pays homage to the
medieval period through canonic
writing. Groups
of voices enter one by one or in imitation; they often enter as voice
groups. This mirrors medieval compositional practice, but here
it becomes a
generator of texture
rather than counterpoint to be heard clearly. The
example above shows how Schnittke deploys this writing, particularly
in the introduction to the piece, orienting us to an imitative allusively "medieval" style, but not
one which will drive the remainder of the piece. His primary technique, to my ear, is not so much canonic writing but rather that of textural design.
TEXTURAL
DESIGN:The piece operates through repeated
two-stage cycles:
1) There is a rapid
expansion of the texture (shown on the spectrogram with those curving
lines that show the basses expanding downward to claim a full
tessitura).
2) We move to what
I think of as exploratory play, with thinner textures revealing a
variety of treatments of the fragments that Schnittke uses as mosaic
tiles.
Each cycle increases the
spectral density and
register width
until we come to the
climactic plateau at 11:39, after which the texture
dissolves and reforms for the final expansion.
If I am right, this assessment shows is that Schnittke’s form in Minnesang is governed
primarily by textural dramaturgy rather than harmonic progression or
melodic recognition.
FLICKERING: For a piece nominally
“about” medieval tunes – and a whole host of those, at that –
the presence of any one tune is remarkably fleeting. Melodies emerge
briefly from the texture and then vanish. Or, in imitation passages
(e.g. 4:54) we might have a cascade of rising lines as one voice, and
then the next, and then the next take over our attention as they work
through their canonic exposition. But these fragments operate at the
level of the phrase, or even half-phrase. We never sit long enough to
“have the tune.” For a piece designed around Minnesang, the
fragments flicker, but do not linger long enough to become a
focus:
a fragment appears
it dissolves a new
fragment appears
The past is never stabilized – it winks in and out.
What the Past Becomes
Taken together, these
features – canonic writing, cycles of expansion and exploratory
thinning, and the fleeting appearance of melodic fragments – shape
the way the medieval material functions in Minnesang.
One
of the most striking things about the piece is that it does not
attempt to restore medieval song as something historically intact.
The tunes themselves rarely stabilize long enough to become
recognizable musical objects. Instead, they surface briefly within
the texture and then dissolve again, reappearing later in altered
contexts. It is the textures and treatments that guide our listening,
not the tunes.
In this sense, the medieval songs operate less as themes than as
sonic artifacts. They provide the raw material for canonic cascades,
for textural expansions, and for the exploratory passages where
fragments briefly step forward before yielding to the next gesture.
What drives the listener’s experience of the piece is therefore not
melodic recognition or harmonic progression, but the unfolding of
textures and the shifting ways those fragments are deployed.
This
distancing of the melodies is reinforced by the way the work treats
its texts. The Middle High German texts are largely unintelligible to
modern listeners, and Schnittke himself tells us that he treats them
primarily as phonetic sound. The melodies appear only in fragments,
rarely long enough to stabilize as recognizable tunes. Even the
stylistic gestures – canon, imitation, layered voices – function less
as historical reconstruction than as textural devices. The result is
that none of the usual grounds for musical judgment quite apply. The text cannot
quite be interpreted, the melodies never quite become themes, and the
style never quite settles into historical pastiche.
The medieval material is therefore present, but at a
remove – circulating within the piece as sound rather than as
historical artifact. Minnesang
does not attempt to recover the medieval past so much as to place it
into motion again. The old songs flicker through the texture, briefly
audible before dissolving back into the larger choral complex. The
past is not restored here. Instead, it is rearranged, reframed, and
reimagined. What remains is not “pastness,” but sound itself: a
field of textures through which the medieval fragments briefly pass.
The medieval does not carry inherent meaning; we cannot quite hold it
in the ear. Yet for Schnittke it becomes a palette of color, applied
here and there until recognizable shapes and patterns emerge.
The result is a paradox that lies at
the heart of Schnittke’s medievalism: the past may be fully
present, even the sole source of melodic material, and yet sound
nothing at all like the past
we imagine.
WORKS CONSULTED
Mark
D. Jennings, 2002. “Alfred
Schnittke's Concerto for Choir : musical analysis and historical
perspectives.” PhD Diss, Florida State.
Zhanna
Lehmann, 2018. “Alfred Schnittke’s quest for a universal musical
language in the Penitential Psalms (1987–88).” Ph.D.
diss., University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.
Dmitri
Smirnov, 2002. Liner notes to Schnittke, A.: Choir Concerto /
Minnesang / Voices of Nature (Holst Singers, Gledhill, Layton),
Hyperion 00602448807229.
In my Western Art Music seminar (a writing seminar, might I add), we
started the term with the early symphony – a little Sammartini, a
little Stamitz, some Martinez, a bit of Haydn. The focus was on
social history. But to bring it forward in time, I’ve done three
things, and it’s really paying off!
First, as an
in-class short-writing exercise, I gave them a 3x5 card, and asked
them what *later* symphony they’d take with them as their only
music for three years on a desert island, and why. Then I let them
add a second piece that they thought would impress their studio
instructor or other faculty mentor. (This is how I take class roll;
it’s also how I get them thinking about how things apply to their
broader musical lives.)
The next day, I put
them in small groups and reminded them of some of the “desert
island” pieces they chose, then ask their groups to create a
chronological timeline of TEN post-Haydn symphony composers, without
computers and without phones. There was a good bit of laughter. Now
who came before that? Who was that composer they played last
semester? Did such-and-so count as a symphony? We put those lists on
the board, and looked at commonalities across all the lists, and who
was missing. It was interesting fodder for the “who decides”
discussion:
We had read the
Donne UK report (scroll past the proms report; the one on symphony
repertoire is down below:
Equality & Diversity in Global Repertoire, 2023/2024 Season) – so they’re definitely starting to see
patterns in their world. So that discussion got rich and interesting.
And then the storm
hit, and we’ve been out of classes for a week. So rather than have
them go off and do something on Machaut with no context, no
background, and no guiding framework, I canceled our Machaut
assignment and moved them back to our desert island:
Okay, here we are in the world. Take 45 - 60 - 90 minutes and listen
to one of those symphonies you mentioned as brilliant, desert-island,
must-engage works. Voxer me with the three things that gave you
shivers (or annoyed you) the most. Focus on the longer works:
Mendelssohn, Schumann, Brahms, Mahler, Stravinsky, etcetera. How does
your chosen work draw on things we saw with our "early symphony"
exemplars? How does it take the basic symphonic ideas we saw in
Sammartini, Haydn, and Martinez, and turn them into something bigger,
stranger, or more intense?
The report-outs have
been lovely. Several went for Tchaikovsky symphonies (which I think
is weird, but I’m only the instructor), and most of them have
spoken to the satisfaction of really listening to something they’ve
wanted to get to know or to re-encounter. And the world is a better
place when we stop and remind ourselves of what we love and what we
came to do.
For me, that’s been the real gift of
this little experiment: not the lists or the timelines, but watching
students slow down long enough to hear why a piece mattered to them
in the first place. In a semester full of deadlines and disruptions,
that kind of listening feels quietly radical. Music makes our lives
better; it’s nice to see them remember that.
So go and listen to whatever first drew
you to music once upon a time. May it bring you comfort now.
An auditory distraction — a crying
baby, a ringing phone — hits like a punch to the gut, instantly demanding our
attention. But recent studies by Mandal and colleagues (2024) suggest that our
minds may be better shielded than we think.
They introduce the idea of an “attentional
earlid.” Just as eyelids can open and shut to regulate what reaches our
eyes, our attention seems to have a mental earlid that blocks irrelevant sounds
from interfering with other tasks.
To test this, Mandal’s team asked
participants to do visual puzzles while irrelevant sounds — simple, pure
sine-wave beeps — popped up in the background. These weren’t meaningful noises
like a person’s name or an odd sound that stood out in context; they were
deliberately boring. Surprisingly, the beeps didn’t slow people down or cause
mistakes. In the face of noise, the earlid held.
But there was a catch. When the
task included listening — for example, counting the number of time a particular
sound occurred — the earlid opened, and the irrelevant beeps slipped in,
pulling at attention. In other words, if your ears are already opened, stray noises evidently sneak through on the same pathway.
This fits with broader psychological
findings: our brain has limited channels of processing, a bit like trying to
carry too many grocery bags. Perceptual load theory (Lavie 1995 is the classic
work) says we only have so much capacity. Mandal’s earlid idea adds another
layer: when sound isn’t part of the job, our brains can shut the door on
irrelevant auditory clutter altogether.
That has real consequences for
musicological me. Much of my work relies on listening-as-study, but the
background noise in our in-town property hovers around 70 dB. Out on the farm,
on the other hand, it drops to the 30s or 40s (unless the turkeys are quarreling).
Thus, in town, my earlids have to contend with a flood of competing input. At
home, the quiet of the countryside acts like a protective layer, letting my
attention settle on the music.
So here’s my observation: if the earlid
is about shutting a door and closing off the sound entirely, then quiet
spaces might work more like sound-glasses: they cut the glare of unwanted
noise so my ears can adjust to what matters most. That may explain why
listening at home, in relative silence, always seems to lead to better prep for
the deeper analysis and meaning-making than the work I do later on campus.
(Huh. I’d always just chalked it up to the distractions of a peopled landscape
once I got to my office.)
I’ll have to think about this more;
I’ve mentioned in other earlid posts
that in my own musical-listening
practice, I see a linkage of left-brain intellectual processing and right-brain
beauty-finding as a strong sound filtering mechanism. The rest of the world can
fall away when I’m working in my musico-analytical space, and even Mandal’s
content disruption – my name – can miss my attention on-ramp. (Sorry, kids!)
I’m not yet sure whether I think that’s an “attentional earlid” or a “sound-glasses” type
phenomenon – or a third thing altogether.
At any rate, today’s browsing in
the literature was a bit dismaying to my prejudices. Maybe, just maybe, those noise-canceling
headphones y’all carry around are actually important as tools to help
manage both attention earlids and sound-glasses. If so, they could be
essential, if unstylish, accessories for those thinking tasks that occupy my
days.
Lavie, N. 1995: Lavie, Nilli. “Perceptual load as a necessary condition for selective
attention.” Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and
Performance, 21/3 (1995): 451–468.
https://doi.org/10.1037/0096-1523.21.3.451
Mandal 2024a: Mandal, A., Liesefeld, A. M.,
& Liesefeld, H. R. “The surprising robustness of visual search against
concurrent auditory distraction.” Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human
Perception and Performance, 50/1 (2024): 99–118.
https://doi.org/10.1037/xhp0001168
Mandal 2024b: Mandal, Ananya, Jan Philipp Röer,
and Heinrich R. Liesefeld. “Auditory Distractors Are Processed but Do Not
Interfere with Visual Search of Any Difficulty When Sound Is Irrelevant.” Visual
Cognition 32/9–10 (2024): 1067–83. doi:10.1080/13506285.2024.2397825.
Tufted titmouse with a call-out saying tweetle tweetle tweetle
In What the Robin Knows, Jon Young suggests that we all follow the practice of sitting and actively listening to birds. He observes that the world birds share with us – that we share with the birds – can be understood through the acoustical signals they send. There’s a background level of noise that is standard, the so-called baseline, and there are the alarm calls and sudden silences that tell us about the “happenings” that the birds are experiencing – ones we can share if we’re paying full attention to their signals. Is that alarm call about us, walking obliviously through the woods, or is it about the nearby fox that we won’t see unless we pay attention?
Paying attention is a challenge, of course. He talks about beginning listeners, and the differences between their experience of soundscape (my word, not his) versus those of more experienced attendees. A bit of explanation first: he uses the term “sit spot” to characterize a place outdoors where one goes to meditate listen repeatedly over time. He recommends these be convenient to the household to encourage frequent practice.
To get at the idea of what listening is, he first gives instructions, and then contrasts two listeners. The task is a simple one: “Listen to the silence and hear all the sounds around you. There will be many in your sit spot.” The results are quite varied:
I always find it instructive to ask new people how many airplanes they heard while sitting in their sit spots. “Three?” one might say hesitantly, after a pause. I may have asked a more experienced individual with a nearby sit spot to be sure to pick up the planes. I turn to her and say, “How many?” “Seven,” she replies. “No way! I can hear a plane. There were three,” the new student argues. “No, there were seven.” The next day, I put that same student in charge of counting planes in his sit spot, and his count goes up. (Young, 2012, p. 59)
Young’s point is that listening isn’t passive—it’s a skill developed over time. Noticing all the layers of sound, even silence, is part of the task:
I like differentiating between the sounds made by the wind as it flows through the branches, the shrubs, the grass – all of them different… Even in the bedroom in the dead of night, there’s plenty to hear. Silence itself has a sound, and listening to it is good practice for picking up the junco’s tiny tunes and alarms. (Young, 2012, p. 59)
He calls for us to adopt what he characterizes as the “Routine of Invisibility,” using an observer’s amble rather than the destination-focused stride of the hiker. This, he argues, will give us more grounding in what is happening within our sphere of observation, since we will avoid becoming that obnoxious thing, the “bird plow” that drives the birds upward toward safety as we move forward into their space. He also makes a strong case for the “interspecies alarm system,” where the listening birds will respond differently (as a group) to the tense, stressed coyote needing to feed its young than to the more relaxed coyote out on an amble – and where the signal that one group of listening birds sets off will be picked up by altogether different species in ways that tend to make all the song-bird species safer. (Unless, of course, there’s a “wake hunter,” the raptor coming along to pick off one of the disturbed birds while it’s distracted. It’s a jungle out there.)
In all, I enjoyed the book, but as my dad says, Young’s notion of the sit spot is not a practice that I’m likely to adopt. My precious outdoor minutes are probably better spent on the walking that keeps me healthy than on the listening stance, if only because it encourages an outdoor stillness that too closely reflects the indoor stillness of the writer’s daily life. But I’ll certainly use Young’s idea of the variability in bird calls – the companion check versus the song vs the adolescent “feed me” demands – as well as his idea of tending to the baseline sounds as part of my outdoor practice.
And as a musicologist, I firmly agree with his ideas that we should all listen to ALL the sounds that we find ourselves immersed in. Awareness, self-discipline, and attentive practice shape how we hear the world. And that’s a takeaway I can get behind.
Young, Jon. What the Robin Knows: How Birds Reveal the Secrets of the Natural World. Mariner Books, 2012/r2013.
Image of female pilgrim with "sounds," "melodies," and "Hallucinations" as responding themes
"Sum-tyme sche herd wyth hir bodily erys sweche sowndys &
melodies that sche myth not wel heryn what a man seyd to hir in that
tyme less he spoke the lowder."
Sometimes she heard with her bodily ears such sounds and melodies
that she might not hear effectively what a man said to her at that
time unless he spoke louder.
Here we see
attention as commodity in the Book of Margery Kempe, that most
idiosyncratic of medieval mystics.
Richard Lawes (2000)
shows that Margery distinguished between the inner sound of visions
(“hire gostly undirstondyng” (her ghostly understanding) and the
external ear-based sounds. He believes that her passing experience
(Sum-tyme) betokens an “auditory hallucination.” This, to him, is
a signal of brain misfirings, and an acoustical experience generated
from an interior rather than exterior source.
I wonder, however,
if she describes here instead a kind of gendered listening. Margery
describes herself as hearing those details of the surrounding
landscape, attending to the “trivial” sounds of background noise,
instead of to the details of the in-person conversation to which she,
particular as a woman, is supposed to be attending. Just as parents
yell, ahem, increase their volume to garner the attention of
their inattentive offspring, so too Margery’s interlocutor
increases his volume to drown out the distracting if more distant
noises. Is the story, then, about a mystical vision? A medical
moment? Or an (admittedly difficult) woman defying expectation? We
should pause and consider context, I think, before deciding that
she’s just hallucinating.
Similarly, Lawes
names the “rushing sounds, likened to a bellows” that are
one-sided, present only in her right ear. As a long-term sufferer of
tinnitus, I suspect that she’s just describing the distracting
internal ear noise to which all such sufferers might be vulnerable.
Again, there are gendered implications; Margery is letting her
experience of self dominate her perceptive world. Would a man,
describing a “rushing like unto a river” be chided for the
experience? Or might it more be wrapped up in assumptions of memory
and experiential displacement?
That is not to say
that Lawes was intending ill by Margery. Rather, I find him an
empathetic reader, if a bit over-fond of his own temporal lobe
epilepsy diagnosis that he believes to be her underlying medical
condition. Still, his assessment and the care he gives to her sensory
details did, IMHO, help to move forward the field of interpretive
writing about her experiences. It’s just that we all come to our
reading with the cultural habits of thought and unconscious biases of
our own generation. And here, picking apart these examples a bit
further does, I think, have something to tell us about the sound
experiences of an important late-medieval laywoman.
Ultimately, Margery
Kempe’s auditory experiences—whether mystical, medical, or
mundane—make me, at least, want to reconsider how we approach
sensory perception and identity in the medieval world. Margery’s
“bodily ears” and their contested sounds challenge us to think
about how gender, culture, and personal experience shape not only
what we hear but also how we interpret it. Was Margery’s listening
“misdirected,” as her contemporaries might have thought, or was
it reflective of a richer and more complex sensory engagement with
her world? Was she, in other words, simply hyper-aware of the world
around her—and if so, shouldn’t we prize that?
RESPONDING TO:
Richard Lawes,
“Psychological Disorder and the Autobiographical Impulse in Julian
of Norwich, Margery Kempe and Thomas Hoccleve,” in Writing
Religious Women: Female Spiritual and Textual Practices in Late
Medieval England, edited by Denis Renevey and Christiana
Whitehead (Toronto: Toronto University Press, 2000): 217-243.
Henry, James. “It is just in Heaven to favor so the
eyes.” [Poem written while walking from Revere to Verona, July 22 and 23, and
in Dresden, Oct. 22, 1865]. Menippea. Dresden: C.C. Meinhold & Sons,
1866, p. 213-14. https://books.google.com/books?id=4G1MAAAAcAAJ&pg=PA213
If one is to spend time on earlids -- and evidently that’s
on the current docket, as my previous posts show (see here and here) – one could
do worse than to spend time with doctor-and-poet James Henry. His
not-particularly-well-known poetry collection Menippea is a staunchly
19th-century product, and one of the untitled poems from the middle of the
collection spends 54 lines considering earlids and their absence.
[There is no closing the
thresholds of the gates. They are open day and night... There is no peace
within, and no silence outside. -- Ovid, Metamorphoses, Bk 12, ll.
45-50]
Is it just in Heaven to favor so the eyes With lids to keep out dust and glare and flies, And leave the poor ears open, night and day, To all each chattering fool may choose to say, To all assaults of sturdy hurdygurd,5 And grand-piano octave, chord, and third, And rapid volley of well-quavered note, Out of wide gaping, husband-seeking throat, And fiddle squeak, and railway whistle shrill, Big drum and little drum and beetling mill,10 Trumpet and fife, triangle and trombone, And hiss and shout and scream and grunt and groan? Be gracious, Heaven! And, if no law forbid, Grant the distracted ear such share of lid That we may sometimes soundly sleep at night,15 Not kept awake until the dawning light, By rattling window-sash, or miauling cat, Or howling dog, or nibbling mouse or rat, Or cooped-up capon fain like cock to crow, Or carts that down the paved street clattering go,20 Or nurse, in the next room, and sickly child, Warbling by turns their native woodnotes wild. Judge us not by thyself, who darest not sleep, But open always, day and night, must keep Both eye and ear, to see and hear how go25 All things above the clouds, and all below; Lids for thine ears, as for thine eyes, were worse Than useless, an impediment and curse; We, with less care, our eyes are free to close At night, or for an after-dinner doze,30 And for this purpose thou hast kindly given, And with a bounty worthy of high Heaven, Each eye a pair of lids. One lid might do For each ear, if thou wilt not hear of two, One large; well fitting lid; and night and day,35 As bound in duty, we will ever pray; And thou with satisfaction shalt behold Our ears no less protected from the cold Than our dear eyes, and never more need’st fear That to thy word we turn a hard, deaf ear;40 Never more fear that discord should arise And jealous bickerings between ears and eyes, Both members of one body corporate, Both loyal subjects of one church and state; Never more see us, on a frosty day45 Stuffing in cotton, or hear caviller say:
“I’d like to know why fallen less happy lot On ear than on snuffbox and mustardpot; What is it ever ear thought or ear did, To disentitle it to its share of lid?”50 Earlids, kind Heaven, or who knows what --?? But no! Silence, rebellious tongue, and let ear go And plead its own case. Lidless, Heaven’s own ear, And, whether it will or not, must always hear.
James’ use of Ovid as epigraph is only that of metaphor;
Ovid doesn’t call to “earlids” specifically, but he does explore the realm of
rumor. Rumor is available night and day, says Ovid; there’s no threshold
closure to keep rumor out. Indeed, such murmurings amplify as we attend to them
(as we must). In other words, gossip will have its sneaky way with folks.
Ovid, Metamorphoses Book XII [= Ovid
on Rumor]
Orbe locus medio est inter
terrasque fretumque
40 caelestesque plagas,
triplicis confinia mundi;
unde quod est usquam, quamvis
regionibus absit,
inspicitur, penetratque cavas
vox omnis ad aures: Fama tenet summaque domum sibi
legit in arce, innumerosque aditus ac mille
foramina tectis 45 addidit et nullis inclusit
limina portis; nocte dieque patet; tota est ex
aere sonanti, tota fremit vocesque refert
iteratque quod audit; nulla quies intus nullaque silentia
parte, nec tamen est clamor, sed parvae
murmura vocis, 50 qualia de pelagi, siquis procul
audiat, undis esse solent, qualemve sonum, cum
Iuppiter atras increpuit nubes, extrema tonitrua
reddunt.
Atria turba tenet: veniunt, leve
vulgus, euntque
mixtaque cum veris passim
commenta vagantur
55 milia rumorum confusaque
verba volutant;
e quibus hi vacuas inplent
semonibus aures,
hi narrata ferunt alio,
mensuraque ficti
crescit, et auditis aliquid
novus adicit auctor.
Illic Credulitas, illic
temerarius Error
60 vanaque Laetitia est
consternatique Timores
Seditioque recens dubioque
auctore Susurri;
ipsa, quid in caelo rerum
pelagoque geratur
et tellure, videt totumque inquirit
in orbem.
There is a place in the middle
of the world, ’twixt land and sea and sky, the meeting-point of the threefold
universe. From this place, whatever is, however far away, is seen, and every
word penetrates to these hollow ears. Rumour dwells here, having chosen her house upon
a high mountain-top; and she gave the house countless entrances, a thousand
apertures, but with no doors to close them. Night and day the house stands
open. It is built all of echoing brass. The whole place is full of noises,
repeats all words and doubles what it hears. There is no quiet, no silence
anywhere within. And yet there is no loud clamour, but only the subdued
murmur of voices, like the murmur of the waves of the sea if you listen afar
off, or like the last rumblings of thunder when Jove has made the dark clouds
crash together. Crowds fill the hall, shifting throngs come and go, and
everywhere wander thousands of rumours, falsehoods mingled with the truth, and
confused reports flit about. Some of these fill their idle ears with talk, and
others go and tell elsewhere what they have heard; while the story grows in
size, and each new teller makes contribution to what he has heard. Here is
Credulity, here is heedless Error, unfounded Joy and panic Fear; here is sudden
Sedition and unauthentic Whisperings. Rumour herself beholds all that is done
in heaven, on sea and land, and searches throughout the world for news.
Ovid Metamorphoses, vol.
2, transl. Frank Justus Miller, The Loeb Classical Library(New York: G.P. Putnam’s Sons, 1926): vol. 2,
pp. 184-185.
ANALYSIS:
James Henry may have been inspired by Ovid, but he goes his own
way in the poem. He considers in the beginning the difference between eyes
(with lids) and ears (without), and alludes to Ovid’s chattering fools who
amplify rumors in so many difficult ways, but he moves quickly (lines 5-12) to
the music that might be blocked out – the hurdygurdy, the piano and its chords,
the voice and its ornamental runs (sung by a young lady to impress the men).
Fiddles, percussion, brass band, and an array of other noises (“hiss and shout
and scream and grunt and groan”) assault the ear.
He turns (lines 13-22) to thinking of the earlid, which
could help us sleep by protecting us from household and neighborhood noises
(blowing windows, cats and dogs, vermin, the neighbors chickens, night-time
carts, and children – the urban equivalents through sheer pervasiveness of
woodland sounds). We are not like God (lines 23-33), who needs to be always
available and is omniscient; we’re able to tune out, to drop our attention and
ignore the world around us. Even a single lid would be better for us, and we’d
give thanks through prayer for having such a tool (lines 34-40). This happy
circumstance would let us treat sight and hearing in parallel, both with the
option of closing down at need. Thus, if snuffboxes and mustardpots warrant
lids, don’t we humans too? (lines 41-50). But no, the poet concludes, we should
be satisfied as-is; lidless ears we have, always open to the world around us –
for good or for ill (51-54).
Earlids here are functioning as a poetic meditation on human
vulnerability and connection. They start as a whimsical notion – a solution to
the cacophony of life – but evolve into a reflection on how we stay open to the
world around us. Henry’s playful logic – his comparisons to mustardpots and
snuffboxes – underscores the absurdity of wishing away our inherent
human-shaped design. Instead, the poem turns our "deficiency" into a
virtue: our lidless ears remind us of our shared humanity. Because of their absence,
we are (happily) unable to fully shield ourselves from the beauty and the
clamor of existence. In a world of noise, our earlidless status keeps us
tethered to both the chaos and the harmony around us. We are always listening,
always, therefore, alive.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Henry, James. “It is just in
Heaven to favor so the eyes.” [Poem written while walking from
Revere to Verona, July 22 and 23, and in Dresden, Oct. 22, 1865].
Menippea.
Dresden: C.C. Meinhold & Sons, 1866, p. 213-14. https://books.google.com/books?id=4G1MAAAAcAAJ&pg=PA213
Ovid Metamorphoses, vol.
2, transl. Frank Justus
Miller, The Loeb Classical Library (New
York: G.P. Putnam’s Sons, 1926):
vol. 2, pp.
184-185.