Showing posts with label gendered agency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gendered agency. Show all posts

Friday, November 6, 2026

What’s yours is mine: a tale of greed at the closure of a monastery


There once were a set of sisters at Talheim bei Mössingen. They lived and prayed and made a life together. And then the Reformation came.

They were beloved of their neighbors, even though, for more than a generation, they stayed on as the Catholic holdovers in a mostly Protestant town. Why do we think so? They served as Godmothers – multiple times – in the local Protestant church register. Religious differences were evidently less important than social connection and pious behavior in the eyes of the broader community.

Such connectedness, however, did not actually help them much when it did come time for the convent to shutter its doors. During these closing years, the convent had been secularized, but the sisters were – in theory – permitted to reside there until death. Theory and practice, however, do not always align.

And this is where our lively cast of characters comes in. Let’s meet them in social-hierarchy order:

  • DUKES: Protestant Duke Ludwig of Württemberg, and his successor Duke Friedrich, generally well-intentioned but not always on top of the details. They know a thing or two about authority, though!
  • ASSISTANCE PROVIDED BY: the Catholic Count of Fürstenberg, where the sisters held properties. He supports them, but sometimes that support takes strange shapes!
  • EVIL-DOING LOCAL NOBLE: Caspar von Karpffen, holder of a quarter of the town of Talheim and always eager for more. See also his daughter Sabina, and Sabina’s husband Christoph von Karpffen: The von Karpffen family demands all the sisters' things – and Caspar holds two sisters hostage until they deed away their property. Then it really gets ugly.
  • FUERSTENBERG BAILIFF from Trochtelfingen: to help with the tussle, he too abducts a sister. “To protect her.” With friends like these, who needs enemies? This act draws the ire of the Württemberg dukes, and then absolutely everyone (except the sisters) engages in a big game of "No, no, no, MY authority."

The story itself goes like this.

In 1593, Caspar von Karpffen imprisoned two sisters in Talheim Castle, supposedly because of offenses they had committed. What offenses? Theodor Schön, whose 1890 account supplies this story, does not explain. Nor is it a one-week lockup situation: he keeps them imprisoned for two years. He finally releases them in 1595, after they sign an agreement to give him all their property. He “generously” promises them an allowance. Insert maniacal laughter clip here.

Because, yeah, the amount he pays them is so small, they couldn’t afford their bread on a daily basis. I guess eating is optional? Anyway, that’s von Karpffen in a nutshell: a nasty piece of work.

Nor was this simply a matter of taking over their fields while leaving the sisters comfortably housed (as the legal agreements stipulated). Oh, no. Silverware, church ornaments, bedding, livestock: their movable possessions went to the von Karpffen household too. And he wasn’t done: after stripping away the means of supporting themselves and the little luxuries like blankets and eating utensils, Karpffen continued to demand that they pay taxes, including the extensive Turkish levy, along with further burdens and exactions. Not even begging could make up this deficit.

And sometimes the help that you get is… complicated. The Count of Fürstenberg intervened, but for reasons that remain obscure to me, his bailiff forcibly removed a sister. “For her protection” is kind of vague. Here, let me abduct you to keep you safe. Ummmm, not sure that’s a win.

Nor was it deemed politically proper. Von Karpffen – in whose territory the sisters still live, be it remembered – complained to Duke Ludwig. In his version of the story, Fürstenberg support was a vile intrusion into Württemberg’s jurisdiction for no reason at all. Instead of asking what was going on (the dukes, not always ones for asking for fussy details like “and what did the victim say”), the duke had the bailiff arrested – and also had him fined 200 guilders. When doing your job actually costs you money; the bailiff wasn’t having a very good day.

So there we are. The first two sisters had been released, but into abject poverty. Another sister has been carried off, and the official response becomes a dispute over whose official was entitled to do what, and where. The women’s predicament had become an occasion for men to defend their rights of government. Neener-neener.

Yet those competing claims also gave the sisters somewhere to turn. Duke Ludwig initially accepted Karpffen’s account, but he wasn’t bad at heart. He actually intervened on the sisters’ behalf once he learned more. Crucially, Schön reports that Ludwig considered the punishment of the sisters beyond Karpffen’s authority. That two-year arrest had been out of bounds.

It was going well for the sisters, but then Duke Ludwig died before he could bring the matter to a satisfactory conclusion. Sigh. His successor, Friedrich, however, continued to work on the intervention, trying to sort through competing claims, and tending to the needs of his subjects, ALL of his subjects.

So what happened? Duke Friedrich reprimanded von Karpffen, and then summoned the parties before the ducal chancellery. But it feels just like a present-day story: the judge commands, but Karpffen failed to appear. Officials went to him. He supplied excuses, poor excuses. Plus, he refused to return the property.

Eventually, under renewed pressure, von Karpffen yielded—but with a reservation, of course. The sisters could have their property back, but after their deaths, he claimed, it should come to him.

The Württemberg officials had other things to do. So they accepted the transfer without actually settling whether that future claim had any validity. For the moment, the women could resume possession, have their land cultivated, gather the harvest, and collect outstanding rents. Most of their property was recovered.

You might think this would be the point at which von Karpffen admitted defeat. You would be wrong.

In July 1601, he had his local official remove the sisters’ hay from their meadows. Hay. They have a showdown over a field of hay.

But hay gets your livestock through the winter. It is an asset: stored nourishment, future milk, the means of keeping your valuable animals alive. How would you like it if the local noble decided to help himself to your vacation fund—and to your winter’s food budget? And then sent you the tax bill on top of that?

Taking the hay was actually an attack on the sisters’ ability to make use of the property they had just recovered. Possession on paper was one thing. Getting the harvest safely home was another. You can tell me what to do, but you can’t make me do it.

So the sisters did what they had to do: they filed another complaint. This time, Friedrich ordered his officials to uphold their restored possession. And on July 27, the Württemberg Schultheiß, a local governing magistrate, arrived at the meadow. Nor did he come alone. Tempers were getting short, and von Karpffen needed a lesson. So the Württemberg magistrate showed up with approximately thirty peasants armed with spears and pitchforks. (Insert visual mob scene from any historic film you’ve ever seen, with raging peasants and a sense of urgency.) They drove away Karpffen’s rival official – and then they hauled off the hay.

Thirty peasants. Spears. Pitchforks. Two competing officials. The hay now had an armed escort.

After which, naturally, came the lawyers.

On April 3, 1602, the two sisters, Veronica Waldträffin and Apollonia Spindlerin, appointed Sebastian Wolf to represent them. I particularly like this detail. These women mostly appear passive in the account; they serve as prisoners, dependents, and objects of protection. Here, on the other hand, we see them taking direct action: securing legal representation to defend their interests. I guess the time had come!

Von Karpffen, meanwhile, obtained a mandate from the Imperial Chamber Court awarding him the disputed hay – or its value if it was no longer available – with a substantial penalty attached to noncompliance. Schön attributes this result to “false representations,” and I’ll take his word on the point, having not read the court records myself. So von Karpffen’s not just a scheming meany; he’s a lying scheming meany. Got it.

Imagine being the sisters. You’ve recovered your property through ducal intervention. Someone takes your harvest. The duke’s men recover it. And now an imperial court says the man who took it is actually owed the hay.

The duke submitted objections. But it’s a legal case; long-lived and complicated. The dispute outlived Caspar von Karpffen, who died in 1603. It also outlived Duke Friedrich, who died in 1608.

Eventually, it outlived the sisters.

And this is where the family connections matter. Caspar had already assigned his claim to the convent to his son-in-law, Christoph, as a marriage portion for his daughter Sabina. Property that still supported living religious women had now been promised as somebody else’s marriage settlement.

Brazen thievery apparently works. After the last sister’s death, Christoph von Karpffen took possession. And, as Schön’s account shows, the convent and its estates subsequently passed through further family marriage arrangements.

What’s yours is mine. And then it’s my daughter’s dowry. And her daughter’s beyond that. And so on, and so on, and so on.

There is one final complication. Schön tells this story with considerable indignation, but his concluding concern is that property intended for religious purposes ended up in private hands. He praises the Württemberg dukes for preserving former Catholic church wealth for Protestant ecclesiastical uses. His preferred outcome was that Württemberg should acquire the estate and devote at least part of it to church purposes.

That makes the dukes’ role worth examining carefully. Their interventions materially helped the sisters. Their interests also extended to what would happen after the women were gone.

For the sisters, meanwhile, the urgent questions were rather more immediate. Could they get their property back? Collect their rents? Keep their bedding? Feed their animals through another winter? Did they ever get their knives, forks, and spoons back?

They had neighbors who named them godmothers, officials who intervened, a lawyer to represent them, and a duke willing to send thirty armed peasants into a meadow.

And still they had to fight for the hay.


WORKS CITED

Gerhard Kittelberger, “Franziskanerinnenkloster Talheim”, Klöster in Baden-Württemberg, http://www.kloester-bw.de/?nr=538. Kittelberger’s entry alerted me to the story. 

Beschreibung des Oberamts Rottenburg, second edition, vol. II (Stuttgart: W. Kohlhammer, 1900), p. 353-4. Includes a summary of the sisters’ Statutes of 1401 and contextual details.

Theodor Schön, “Die letzten Schicksale des Beguinenklosters zu Thalheim im Oberamt Rottenburg,” Blätter für württembergische Kirchengeschichte 5 (1890): 82–84. Best German-language rendition of the story. 

And yes, I enjoyed this tale well enough to pursue it bibliographically even though it WASN'T on my list of things to do! 


YOU MIGHT ALSO BE INTERESTED IN

Kin, Cash, and Convent: Providing for Nieces (and Nephews) in 1613 Bludenz: A determined aunt uses her will to support a niece’s religious future—with conditions attached. Another encounter with convents, inheritance, and the family politics of deciding who gets what.

When the Gestapo Came for the Sisters: A much later chapter in the history of forced convent closures, drawn from testimony preserved in the Nuremberg Trial records. The consequences reached beyond cloister walls into schools, charitable work, and the communities the sisters served.

Listening in on the Nuns’ Rebellion at Kloster Goldenstein: What happens when sisters refuse to accept that someone else has finished deciding where they belong? Three elderly nuns of the present-day reclaim their convent, and their familiar sounds of prayer and daily life become an assertion of their right to remain.

Wednesday, January 22, 2025

When a 6-year-old brought a Marian Icon to Thalbach (1/22/25)

Bregenz Parish church (E) and, perhaps, Thalbach (yellow), from Copperplate of M.Meriam, 1643

In July of 1588, Catarina Haidenhoferin from Ravensburg arrived in the monastery of Thalbach in Bregenz. She was, at the time, six years old, but her monastic career was auspicious. She eventually became the convent’s Meisterin in 1641, at age 59 (by my calculation), and served until her death in May 1664. She took holy orders at age fourteen or fifteen in August of 1596, and made her profession on 27th of October 1599, tucking her in among the monastic sisters of the 16th century.

The story of Catarina arrival’s is seen by the convent chroniclist as remarkable, since her natal city of Ravensburg was at the time mostly Lutheran. Nevertheless, the family’s Catholic faith remained staunch, as witnessed not just through Catarina’s monastic dedication, but also through the story of her arrival, as the chroniclist tells it:

A Lutheran baker wanted to throw our dear lady's Vespers picture into the oven and burn it, but the mother of this 6-year-old child saw this and asked the baker not to do this but to give her this little Marian picture, and she would give him other wood if he wanted, which was also done.

Afterwards she sent the original Mary or Vespers picture with the child to the monastery, which is still in the church on the right hand side, in the choir of the same place in which St. Ursula is grouped with four virgins, of whom the eleven thousand had been previously venerated, but this Vespers picture was recently kept and venerated. (Bregenz VLA, Kloster Thalbach Hs 9 Thalbach Chronicle, p. 19. Transcription/translation by the author.)

Our chroniclist is doing several things here. She is first telling a story of the miraculous rescue of an image of the Virgin, the so-called “Vesperbild,” rescued by a devout family in a “remarkable” intervention. (Such pictures were frequently the focus of specific prayers, and particularly, of Vesper services, when the singing of the Magnificat could be enhanced by the contemplation of the Virgin's image.) The Catholic hero of the story, Catarina’s mother, had to be in the right place at the right time; had to convince a Lutheran tradesman not to consign the picture to the flames; had to bribe him with substitute wood. Moreover, this mother’s faith was evidently strong enough to rescue the picture from this hotbed of Lutheranism and send not just it but her small child to a Catholic sanctuary – and not just any monastery, this monastery of Thalbach, one in a Catholic stronghold.

This, of course, raises important questions of gendered agency in the context of contested religious identity. We hear of the mother’s actions, but not the father’s. We also learn here of the young age of Caterina’s arrival as a six-year-old Catholic girl finding home with Catholic sisters of Thalbach. Notably, the Chroniclist centers the age of arrival in many of her reports of Convent sisters, and the majority of these “early arrivals” (pre-14 year olds), at least in her telling, choose a monastic vocation upon maturity. It is also interesting that the only man in this particular story is the baker, who was about to perform an act that Catholics would consider sacrilege. The women of the story – the mother, child, and arguably the Virgin herself – turn what could have been a crisis of his making into a pivot-point towards Catarina’s future monastic success.

The chroniclist is also telling a story of Catholic persistence in regions that are (from her vantage point) uncomfortably Lutheran. Since, at the time, Bregenz was firmly positioned in the Counter-reformation camp and was Catholic to the near-exclusion of other faith practices, she’s telling a story of “our side’s” success in the face of oppression in other lands. That Catarina – eventual leader of the convent – came from Lutheran lands shows, suggests the Chroniclist, a hint of divine providence. The 10-hour walk from Ravensburg to Bregenz might only have been a few hours on horseback, but the arrival of a 6-year-old from a place as remote as Ravensburg is itself worthy of mention, even without the gift of precious artwork that accompanied her.

This story is also an explanatory story which tells of convent treasure and its derivation. It is a specific image, identified not by internal visual clues but by location. It is that image which stands in the corner of St Ursula, “on the right hand side in the choir.” It is, moreover, an image of the virgin, acquired at nearly the same time as the convent came to own the miraculous statue of the Virgin (the 13th century Gnadenmutter) which still adorns their chapel. The Virgin, in other words, is being made visibly manifest through these miraculous arrivals. (The story of the statue’s arrival at Thalbach is told in a number of places, and perhaps I’ll retell it in a later post. Stay tuned.)

And lastly, this is an anticipatory story, for Caterina Haidenhoferin was to feature in the reform of Thalbach’s liturgy. But that is a story I will tell another day.

NOTE:
I use the term chroniclist rather than the masculine-gendered chronicler that abounds in the literature. I follow Catarina’s own spelling of her name from Bregenz, Vorarlberger Landesarchiv Klosterarchiv Box 15, Folder #225, document of 1649.

THALBACH CHRONICLE: Bregenz, Vorarlberger Landesarchiv, Kloster Thalbach Hs 9, Chronik des Klosters 1336-1629.

THALBACH’S GNADENBILD: A story told several places, including these: 

  • “Wie das alte Bild der Gnadenmutter von Mehrerau nach Talbach kam,” Holunder Wochen-Beilage für Volkstum, Bildung und Unterhaltung zur Vorarlberger Landes-Zeitung, Jg. 15 (1937), Nr. 40, S. 1 – 2. 
  •  “Das marianische Gnadenbild zu Thalbach bei Bregenz.” Monat-Rosen zu Ehren der Unbefleckten Gottes-Mutter Maria 14 (1884-5): Heft 1, Beilage, pp. 48-53. https://books.google.com/books?id=kKPi0ihULl4C
(I need to dig up the rest of my bibliography on the Thalbach Gnadenbild from my files from pre-pandemic days, and am putting that on my to-do list now!)

What does HMML sound like?

HMML has for me a distinct array of sounds. I thought a little Tell-and-Show might capture some untold aspects of my fellowship time. F...