Showing posts with label prayer gestures. Show all posts
Showing posts with label prayer gestures. Show all posts

Sunday, October 25, 2026

Fiery Fingers and Working Hands: Prayer at the Grevenconvent


If you were a Sister in 15th century Grevencloster in Cologne, you would already have made a decision to devote your life to prayer. And to other duties, of course – Tertiary sisters as a whole were known for their contributions to the social good. And it’s nice to sleep, occasionally. Or so I’m told.

So our hypothetical Grevencloster sister is sitting in her convent, thinking to herself: golly, I should pray. But some days, prayer is just inspiring, and other days, well, keeping your mind on your spiritual practices can be a challenge.

There’s a self-help book for that.

The sisters of the Grevenconvent owned a substantial manuscript, now Köln HAStK 7010 155: 310 leaves, or 620 pages, copied in two columns. It contains a dialect-inflected vernacular version of the Vitaspatrum, a collection of lives, sayings, and stories about the early Christian desert fathers. Its advice is provided through a series of encounters: someone asks a question, an elder or other authority answers, and each small story gives the reader something to think about.

The twelfth book – chapter, in modern parlance – is devoted to prayer. Across thirteen sayings and stories, it offers examples of extraordinary devotion alongside advice for getting through a regular plain old day. And it begins with a reassuring admission: concentration is hard. We all need to keep practicing:

1. Abbot Agathon: the labor of prayer: The brothers once asked Abbot Agathon which virtue required the greatest labor in the community. He replied: “Brothers, I think there is no greater labor than praying to God. For whenever a person prays to his God, immediately the devil seeks to disrupt his prayer, because they know that nothing hinders them so greatly as prayer. In every other labor within the community, a person has some rest; prayer, however, requires a good struggle until the end.”

Prayer, our reader learns, is hard, but worthwhile. Even the desert fathers, with lives that were exemplary enough to be collected and copied centuries later, recognized the difficulty of sustaining prayer. Agathon gives that difficulty a spiritual explanation: the devil is a disruptor, and prayer interferes with his business. Expect resistance, but keep on keeping on.

But how does one keep praying while also doing everything else? Abbot Lucius has an answer—and a pointed question for people who claim to have solved that problem already.

4. Abbot Lucius: praying without ceasing: Once some monks called “the Prayers” (Anbedere) came to Abbot Lucius at Ennatho. The abbot asked them what manual work they did. They said: “We undertake no manual work. Rather, as the Apostle says, we pray without ceasing.”

The elder said: “Do you not eat or sleep?” They answered: “Yes.” He said: “Then who prays for you?” They did not know how to answer him.

Then he said: “Brothers, you do not do what you say. But I will show you that I work with my hands and nevertheless pray without ceasing. With God’s help, I sit making mats from palm leaves, and meanwhile I say, Miserere mei, Deus—‘Have mercy on me, O God.’ Is that not prayer?” They said: “Yes.”

The elder continued: “When I have worked and prayed like this throughout the day, I earn sixteen pennies, more or less. Of these I give two to the poor at the door, and they pray for me while I eat and sleep. Thus in me is fulfilled what is written: ‘Pray without ceasing.’”

Clever story, eh? Reinforces the idea that prayer is in the intention, and that keeping the intention in focus while also accomplishing the more plebian “work of the world” – here, mat-making; in the convent, perhaps spinning or stitching or polishing the silver – turns work-time into prayer time. And then, too, a person can give alms to add other’s prayers to his or her own, and that will allow for a ceaseless chorus of prayers to rise up to the heavens.

For a sister with work to do, this offers an appealing possibility. A repeated prayer can accompany the familiar movements of repetitive tasks. Plus, the community of prayer can extend beyond the person doing the praying. Nor is this a distraction, as she read about before, but an effective use of all available time to accomplish multiple ends, here a combination of physical labor and the spiritual task of prayer. It doesn’t have to be one or the other.

Still, the sister may feel that as far as prayer goes, she’s walking through the motions. She already prays the hours (as the rule commands). But a prayer life can still leave plenty of room for spiritual ambition. Lot, who has established his own routine, wants to know what comes next.

3. Abbot Lot and Abbot Joseph: becoming fire: Abbot Lot came to Abbot Joseph and said to him: “According to my ability, I fulfil my little rule: I observe a little fasting, prayer, meditation, and stillness, and I strive as best I can to purify my thoughts. What more should I do?”

Then the elder stood up and raised his hands toward heaven, and his fingers shone like fire. He said: “If you wish to become entirely like fire, do not stop at what you have already attained.”

That is quite an answer to “What more should I do?” Lot gives us a modest inventory of his practices. Sounds like a good monastic existence. Joseph makes us realize that prayer can go beyond the ordinary: fiery fingers here are echoed in the story of Abbot Sisoes, who achieves rapture while at prayer – as long as he strikes the right attitude

11. Abbot Sisoes: rapture during shared prayers: It was said of Abbot Sisoes that whenever he stood in prayer, unless he quickly lowered his hands, he was immediately caught up in rapture (ghetucket). When another brother happened to pray with him, he quickly lowered his hands so that he would not be caught up in rapture and cause any delay.

But back to the Lot example: I’m particularly taken with its final directive: if you are seeking fiery levels of inspiration, “do not stop at what you have already attained.” The Latin version of this story ends with the invitation to become entirely like fire. The Grevenconvent manuscript gives its reader an additional push. Lot’s “little” observances have brought him to a point from which he can now go further; he gets an implicit exhortation to intensity. The combination of these two “fiery prayer” stories reminds us that spirituality can be exciting, transformative, unearthly. It has the capacity for a “wow” of a spiritual moment.

But not every moment trends toward the extraordinary. The smaller in-the-moment prayers matter too. When people ask Macarius how to pray, for instance, he doesn’t require a lot of text:

13. Abbot Macarius: how to pray: Some people asked Abbot Macarius how they should pray. He said: “There is no need to say much. Rather, continually stretch out your hands and say: ‘Lord, as you will and as you know best, have mercy on me.’ But if a temptation enters the mind, we should say: ‘Lord, help me.’ For he knows well what is beneficial for us, and deals mercifully with us here.”

At times of temptation, short and sweet is the best solution: “Lord, help me.” It’s almost akin to a mantra, and can cut into that jumble of thoughts to turn the devotee back toward her duty. It is also a text that can be said while your hands are occupied. The Macarius exemplum gives the reader both words to use when the need arises, and the assurance that God already understands what is needed. Eloquence isn’t required.

He also gives her something to do: stretch out the hands, and do so continually. This reminds us that prayer is embodied. Joseph raises his hands toward heaven; elsewhere in the chapter, Bessarion stands praying with his hands raised, and an elder raises his hands to ask for rain. Prayer takes bodily form as well as spoken form; it is something you do, not just something you say.

Taken together, these stories offer several avenues into prayer. There is struggle for focus, repetition and practice, prayer to accompany work. Three’s generosity, appropriate bodily gesture, and the possibility of becoming like fire. There are even a few words for that moment when eloquence fails you.

And tucked among the longer encounters is a very short saying:

12. The old fathers: prayer orders the thoughts: The elders said: “Continual prayer sets the thoughts in order.”

That sense of order and alignment with what is good in the world is a reward in its own right. As they read, then, the sisters could find both encouragement for the prayer they already practiced alongside an invitation to imagine what more it might become. For our Grevenconvent reader, the next prayer might involve struggle, a steadier mind, or something extraordinary; this spiritual how-to manual gave her reasons to keep going.


For anyone who would like to explore the whole chapter, here is an outline of its thirteen sayings and stories, in manuscript order. The titles and numbers are supplied by me.

No. Title (supplied) Contents
1 Agathon: prayer as lifelong struggle Prayer encounters continual opposition and requires struggle until the end.
2 Dulas on Bessarion: prayer and miracles Prolonged prayer, miraculous water, and prophecy. Gesture: standing with hands raised to heaven.
3 Lot and Joseph: becoming entirely like fire Joseph challenges Lot to go beyond his accustomed practices. Gesture: Joseph rises and raises his hands; his fingers shine like fire.
4 Lucius: praying without ceasing Manual work, spoken prayer, and almsgiving together sustain continual prayer.
5 An elder from Mount Sinai: prayer for rain An elder’s prayer ends a drought. Gesture: he raises his hands; the brother falls down before him, and the elder flees.
6 Isaiah: prayer rising like fire A priest of Pelusium calls for silence because one brother’s prayer rises like fire before God.
7 Pastor: the imperfect harvest Giving with imperfect motives is better than withholding help altogether.
8 An elder and visiting brothers: prayer beneath conversation One brother completes 103 prayers while conversing with the others.
9 An elder: the soul as clear water Contemplative prayer requires purification from extraneous thoughts.
10 Evagrius: the sword of tears Tears combat intrusive thoughts during prayer.
11 Sisoes: rapture during shared prayer Sisoes avoids being caught up in rapture and delaying his companion. Gesture: to avoid rapture, he quickly lowers his hands.
12 The old fathers: prayer orders the thoughts A brief maxim on continual prayer and inner discipline.
13 Macarius: a few words suffice Simple appeals for mercy and help suffice. Gesture: stretching out the hands in prayer.

All translations above -- based on my own transcription of Köln HAStK 7010 155, fols. 40r–41v -- are provisional, intended to convey the flavor and contents of the chapter; they have not yet been polished for scholarly publication. Numbers and anecdote headers were supplied for tracking purposes throughout.

For an accessible English translation based on the Latin transmission of Book V – a later part of the collection – see The Desert Fathers: Sayings of the Early Christian Monks, translated with an introduction by Benedicta Ward (London: Penguin Books, 2003).

Image: “Mathilde Standing with Hands Raised in Prayer,” from the Helmarshausen Psalter, Germany, second half of the twelfth century, Walters Art Gal+lery W.10, fol. 6v


YOU MIGHT ALSO BE INTERESTED IN:

Margaret of Hungary Does Pilates?: Kneeling, bowing, holding a position—and doing it all again. Explore what the testimony about Margaret reveals about the physical effort and repeated movements of medieval prayer. 

Seven Times a Day: Prayer as Humane Practice: Why repeat a prayer seven times today, then return to it tomorrow? Instructions in a Thalbach prayerbook suggest how repetition helped sustain devotion through fluctuating attention and ordinary daily life.

Dominican Prayer Gestures: Raised hands belong to a much larger vocabulary of devotional movement. This post explores how bows, kneeling, and prostrations made prayer visible—and gave readers actions to imitate.

Supple Rules for Prayer: Daston’s Ideas Meet the 16thc Prayerbook: Prayerbooks supplied practical guidance about where to stand, what to look at, and how to prepare for sleep. Consider how these instructions could guide devotion while leaving room for individual circumstances. 

Friday, June 6, 2025

The 1507 South Wall Frescoes of Brand’s Parish Church (Vorarlberg)

Walk into the Parish church of Brand in Brandnertal, Vorarlberg, Austria, and you’ll notice several things.

The first is that the church is a curious mix of Gothic and modern, redesigned in modern times to adapt to the needs and size of a large and growing local congregation. The two sections are distinct, the warm wood tones of the modern addition from the 1960s contrasting with the largely white-plaster walls of the Gothic section, known to have been consecrated by the Auxiliary Bishop of Chur, Stephan Tschuggli in 1507 (Fragments, p. 4). 

Brand (Vorarlberg) Parish Church, Exterior 

Second, as an active church, the Church of the Assumption of Mary (Mariä Himmelfahrt) houses an array of Catholic devotional items. Modern flowers and candles are paired with early modern statuary; two sets of rosary beads and a few polished pieces of pink quartz sit before another mother-and-child with not one but two apples. And, of course, fliers and announcements for upcoming programs are readily available near the entryway.

But to a medievalist, the most striking feature of the Brand church would definitely be its Swiss-influenced frescoes, rediscovered in 1942 by restorer and painter Toni Kirchmayr (Fragments, p. 8). Today’s post focuses on the South wall, where six maroon-framed images remind us that churches of the early sixteenth century were colorful, highly-illustrated places.


LEFT (3 Holy women plus Anna Selbdritt with donors)

Brand (Vorarlberg): Fresco featuring 3 Holy Virgins (above) and Anna as mother of Mary (below)

As the photo shows, the first pair of images of the South wall – the set to the left – focus on women. On top, the three Holy Virgins, St Margaretha with her cross (though her trampled dragon is now obscured by the centuries underneath plaster), as well as St Barbara and St Katharina appear.

Below, we find Anna as mother, coiffed in an oversized headdress and holding the young Mary. They are adored by two donors, identified with coats of arms. We catch the left-hand donor in a moment of prayerful contemplation, hands together and held at a 45-degree angle upwards with a rosary draped and dangling, a message of devotional intent from a mere decade before the reformation.

Brand (Vorarlberg): Donor with rosary and coat of arms

MIDDLE (Three Male Saints and the Immaculata)

The panel of women are matched in the middle pillar by an image of three male saints, this time with banderoles, though lamentably the text is not preserved and the saints have not heretofore been identified; I offer a tentative identification below. 

Brand (Vorarlberg) Fresco: Three male saints (above), and the Immaculata (below)
These three men are all bearded and haloed. Figure 1 holds something at waist height. It appears to be mechanical, since his thumb is pressing a lever and there is some kind of gear and screw configuration. This is likely the windlass of St Erasmus, a gruesome reminder of the torture he faced.

Brand (Vorarlberg): Erasmus with his windlass
If Erasmus is present, and grouped with both the Holy Virgins of the previous panel and male companions here, it seems likely that this complex is part of an elaborate depiction of the 14 Holy Helpers, the Nothelfer, whose veneration was widespread at the time. Using that framework, we can try to identify the other two men posed with Erasmus.

Figure 2 has two layers of cloth over head and shoulders and is wrapped in his cloak; he is more subdued in his movements; his arm seems to hang down, for it is lower than that of our putative Erasmus. He has a grey beard but with a darker mustache, perhaps to evoke his long-suffering life, showing both age and remembered strength. This could be St Eustace, often depicted as one of the more passive of the Nothelfer.

Figure 3 is bareheaded with abundant hair, and holds his left hand palm up with pointer and middle finger curled upwards. Given the gesture, this could well be St Cyriacus, who  was an exorcist.

At the bottom right-hand edge, a much smaller figure peeks up at the three saints, emerging from the frame. Given its size and location, this is likely a donor image.

Below these male saints appear in the panel above another image of Mary, identified as the Immaculata (Fragments, p. 6), though many of the details have been lost.  

Brand (Vorarlberg): Mary Immaculata

She is depicted as a young pregnant woman set against a sunburst of wavy rays, and she stands on something, though, like Margaretha, we can only guess at whether or not it was a crushed dragon. (It seems more likely that they are rocks.)

Like the donor of the previous set of images, Mary’s hands are waist-high and upright, raised in prayer, but unlike the donor, whose palms touched, Mary intentionally steeples her fingertips to create a triangular space above her swelling abdomen. The triangle can be read as an allusion to the Trinity, and we are invited to see Mary as the “Vas spirituale,” the spiritual vessel, bearer of Christ the redeemer. (I have written on Dominican prayer gestures in a previous post, though that discussion was more about posture than hand gesture.)

This interpretation of Mary's role as a vessel of grace is reinforced by other elements of the fresco. Mary’s gaze is drawn to a serpent, the representation of her purity a stark contrast with the evil of sin.

Likewise, in the upper left corner, we see an angel holding a chalice and a crown. The chalice is closer to Mary than is the crown. That is, this is not a depiction of the crown on offer but rather one in which the promise of a crown is glimpsed. Why? The pregnant Mary is only mid-way through her difficult journey, not yet serving as Regina Caeli (Queen of Heaven) but rather preparing herself to be the receptacle of grace.

The other corner may once have held a second angel but that image is, alas, effaced.


RIGHT (Harrowing of Hell and Four Men)

The panel on the right changes up the thematic content. This time, there are four male figures in the lower image, and above we see the Harrowing of Hell, with the released souls emerging from their graves. 

Brand (Vorarlberg): The Harrowing of Hell (above), and four male figures (below)

The bodies emerging from the graves in the upper panel are the holy dead; they have halos and are naked or, like the right-most figure, are in simple shifts. The central figure of the group, however, is in a dark fur-lined coat and is assisting the others over the tomb edge. Above, a majestic haloed figure stands. Banderoles, both for the heavenly figure(s) and for those emerging from the grave would have helped contemporaries interpret the story.

The four men in the lower image are less easily identified. Of the four, two wear hats (of different sorts) and two do not. At least three of the four men have beards; the right-most figure might be clean-shaven. One of the men looks at us and seems to be smiling; the other three look outside of our scene and have more serious expressions. None have halos, though the four do stand against a lighter bit of sky – a cloud, or the glow of sunrise both come to mind.

Could these be patrons, gazing (mostly) on the Immaculata of the previous panel? Or are they patriarchs, without halos? And why is there space running along the left-hand edge – are they by a shore, perhaps? Or was there meant to be a fifth figure? Why was the order inverted – why are these men not in the upper panel like the saints of the other sets? Was the artist ensuring that we read them as secular figures? The image leaves more questions than answers.

SUMMARY

On this Southern wall of the Brand church, we have two images of Mary – to whom the church is dedicated, of course – and one of Christ’s freeing of souls from limbo. We also have six saints –  three women and three men – plus an additional panel of four men. And we have the two adoring patrons of the first pair of images, actively pursuing devotional prayer as a model for the congregants who gathered in this space. 

Such images were meant to activate the church's space. They called the viewer to remember particular biblical stories, they reminded the viewer of the presence and support to be had from the saints, and they modeled the practices and postures of prayer, as we saw with the donor and rosary. They served, in other words, as a distinctive testament to pre-Reformation faith in the Walser areas of Alpine Vorarlberg.

To me, the south wall’s frescoes are a kind of devotional anchor for the parish – rooted, orderly, and densely populated with saints and familiar sacred moments. Our donor figures here are both observers and participants, integrated into the sacred story. It's almost as if they are inviting parishioners to imagine themselves there, too. 

I’m also struck by the sense of continuity that these images suggest. The saints act as intercessors, protectors, and models, and are placed alongside Marian devotion and Christological scenes in a way that feels almost liturgical.  

Eamon Duffy reminds us in The Stripping of the Altars that late medieval English parish churches were “full of presence,” filled with images, rites, and smells that made the divine tangible. The same clearly applies here in late medieval Vorarlberg. This wall’s carefully choreographed figures were likely central to local rhythms of prayer and memory – not just passive decoration, but a kind of visual litany embedded in the painted plaster that made the church so resplendent.

WORKS CITED:

[Anonymous]. Parish Church “Our Lady of the Assumption” Brand: Fragments from the Church History Chronicles of Brand / Vorarlberg. [Undated Church Pamphlet.] Cited as "Fragments."

Cyrus, Cynthia. "Dominican Prayer Gestures" [blog post], Silences and Sounds, 3/29/25 https://silencesandsounds.blogspot.com/2025/03/dominican-prayer-gestures-32925.html.

Duffy, Eamon. The Stripping of the Altars: Traditional Religion in England, 1400-1580. New Haven: Yale UP, 1992/R2022.

Note: The photos – taken by the author in July 28, 2025 with an iPhone 12 (!) – have been adjusted to bring out image details. The author is happy to provide untouched originals if needed. Photos and text are CC BY-SA: You are free to share and adapt this material, provided appropriate credit is given; any derivative works must be distributed under the same license.





Saturday, March 29, 2025

Dominican Prayer Gestures (3/29/25)

Medieval prayer was not just a matter of words – it was a full-bodied practice, shaped by movement, posture, and gesture. As Jean-Claude Schmitt observes, such “[g]estures do not derive their meaning from their form but from their social use, from the context in which they were carried out” (p. 133). That is, we understand the significance of certain ways of holding the body and arms from the space in which they occur, the person or persons carrying them out, and the framing activities in which they are embedded.

This post briefly explores three twelfth- and thirteenth-century sources that illuminate the role of gesture in Dominican prayer: Peter the Chanter’s reflections on movement in devotion, Humbert of Romans’ structured taxonomy of bows and prostrations, and the treatises on Saint Dominic’s own prayer postures.

Together, these perspectives reveal how physical expression was not only an outward sign of inner devotion but also a communicative act, shaping and reinforcing the experience of prayer for both the individual and the community.

Peter the Chanter (d. 1197) tells us that prayer is a continuous movement. Take, for instance, his praise of the French at the moment of transubstantiation in the mass: 

these god-fearing men, I say, not only bend their head and kidneys but also remove all their hoods and caps from their heads, [and] prostrate themselves and fall on their face during the making and taking of the flesh and blood of Christ.

Four verbs in one short description: prayer for Peter is both active and sequential. Because of this, he considers gesture to be foundational for the act of praying. The positionality of the body matters in appropriately signaling the state of mind and spirit with which the petitioner approaches prayer. Here, Richard Trexler reminds us, we have submission postures. But to gesture, Peter reminds us, is an action, not an attitude. From a modern perspective, it’s a revelation of energy expended as well as engagement with the moment. Even when held in stasis – as with extended kneeling – the petitioner is putting physical energy into the act of prayer to supplement the verbal energy of the spoken prayer itself. Movement matters.

Trexler rightly points to the inconsistencies among the depictions as well as inconsistencies in Peter’s construction of the biblical authenticity for the seven gestures he articulates. Nevertheless, these “devote postures” are crafted to provide models of action in prayer. As Trexler summarizes, 

Peter the Chanter knew that the most sophisticated reader would learn body motions more quickly through pictures, and he wanted clerks to then act out his seven modes of prayer in a fashion which would edify spectators. Depersonalized figures would teach clerks, whose ritual life would then be the "book of the simple" (Trexler, p. 110).

Humbert of Romans (1200-1277) agrees with Peter the Chanter, at least in part: gesture matters, and it is imitable. Humbert, however, is less taken with ideas of movement and more with its visual endpoints. He offers a gestural grammar that explore the patterns of bending bodies in the context of the liturgy. Humbert provides a six-fold matrix of bows (inclinationes), genuflections (genuflexiones), and prostrations (prostrationes):

In his assessment of Humbert’s discussion, scholar Dmitri Zakharine points out that prostrations were an extended form of genuflection – “an amplification of the genuflection in liturgical ceremony.” (Zakharine, p. 349). He notes, however, that all these gestures had communicative power: they meant something to the petitioner, and, equally, they meant something to those who viewed these gestures.

It’s not unlike the teenager, arms akimbo. There is an authority of attitude inherent in these gestures if we see them in their proper context. For that teen with attitude, we’re mere steps away from the eye roll and the snarky comment. For the prayer-giver, we are in an opposite space, one in which the attitude reinforces a petitioning stance in the adoratio of the liturgy.

And Saint Dominic (1170-1221) himself explored a variety of stances in his prayer, at least as recorded in the multiple copies of The Nine [Alt: Fourteen] Ways of Praying of St Dominic. As Schmitt explores in detail, the illustrations to the Dominican treatise give us a wide range of gestures that Dominic was thought to have modeled.

That passive voice is doing some important work, because while the treatises agree in their hagiographical intent, they disagree, at least in part, about which prayer gestures were important enough to include. As Schmitt puts it, “the saint’s gestures quickly escaped pre-established codification of the inclinations” (Schmitt, p. 133).

The discussions of Dominic’s prayer in the treatise make clear that the captured gestures illustrated in the treatise iconography are part of a broader gestural complex. Take Dominic’s act of reading “some book opened before him.” Schmitt quotes the treatise: “He venerated his book, inclined himself toward it, kissed it with love.” In other words, the saint responded emotively and acted out his impulses in a set of actions – kissing the book, but also covering his head with his hood, or turning away from the book as if overwhelmed by its content. (Schmitt, p. 133)

This is important, because, pace Schmitt, the images and texts “offered a type of practical manual, a guide where the images presented more accurately the description of the gestures and moreover, the movement to imitate” (Schmitt, p. 140). In other words, the wise viewer might use the image as a model, for there is an “imitability” between friar and saint, reinforced by the choice of the vernacular. 

CONCLUSION

Given the differences in what they have to say, Peter, Humbert, and Dominic give us a rich view of medieval prayer gesture. For Peter the Chanter, the action is at the center of the gesture. These gestures reinforce the embodied nature of the petitioner, the life behind the words on the page or spoken into the air. For Humbert, the grammar of gesture is a central concern. He’s trying to think through the categories of meaningful acts, to give us the geometry of suitable self-abnegation, as the petitioner humbles him or herself before god. For Dominic, gesture is part of an almost theatrical construct, a staging in which bodily responses reinforce and make manifest the affective power of prayer.

Much like the implicit codes of modern body language, medieval prayer gestures carried with it meaningful information, shaping and being shaped by those who performed and witnessed them. Schmitt makes the point that prayer gestures were open to scrutiny by all – that one could see the forms of the prayer even if the words were only sub-vocal. Even in silence, the body spoke, making devotion visible to all who had eyes to see.


RESOURCES

Humbert of Romans. “Expositio super constitutiones fratrum praedicatorum.” In Opera Omnia, edited by Joachim Joseph Berthier, vol. 2: 160-167. Stuttgart: Klett Cotta, 1888-1889.

Schmitt, Jean-Claude. “Between Text and Image: the Prayer Gestures of Saint Dominic.” History and Anthropology 1 (1984): 127-162.

Trexler, Richard C. “Legitimating Prayer Gestures in the Twelfth Century. The De Penitentia of Peter the Chanter.” History and Anthropology, 1 (1984): 97-126.

Zakharine, Dmitri. “Medieval Perspectives in Europe: Oral Culture and Bodily Practices.” In Body - Language - Communication, Volume 1, edited by Cornelia Müller, Alan Cienki, Ellen Fricke, Silva Ladewig, David McNeill, Sedinha Tessendorf, pp. 343-364. Handbücher zur Sprach- und Kommunikationswissenschaft, 38,1. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 2013.

What does HMML sound like?

HMML has for me a distinct array of sounds. I thought a little Tell-and-Show might capture some untold aspects of my fellowship time. F...